Kulern
Sempai
- 26 Feb 2026
- 184
- 192
The Manga is amazing however. But i feel the Anime just dont do it justice
Flaws
- Rose holding a gun confuses the whole point of her character, she does it in both animes. 2002 one and Brotherhood one (In the manga she never does so. Since the whole point of her being religious "In this specific sense of it", is that she uses that as an excuse to not accept the consequences for loss in her life, or dealing with that harsh reality. Which keeps her in a bubble. So she never truly grew as a person). Adding a gun to the scene just... makes no sense what so ever in the anime?
- Music is too heroic at times. If Mustang is firing flames at me, i want the music to be "I AM BUUURNING NOOO MY FLESH IS MELTING!"
Aka i dont think heroism fits here type of music
(My headcanon to how it should sound like but.. its debatable)
But its just. The whole vibe of the anime... it just doesnt do the manga justice is all? Its a great told story. But the anime i just dont think its it yknow?
Flaws
- Rose holding a gun confuses the whole point of her character, she does it in both animes. 2002 one and Brotherhood one (In the manga she never does so. Since the whole point of her being religious "In this specific sense of it", is that she uses that as an excuse to not accept the consequences for loss in her life, or dealing with that harsh reality. Which keeps her in a bubble. So she never truly grew as a person). Adding a gun to the scene just... makes no sense what so ever in the anime?
- Music is too heroic at times. If Mustang is firing flames at me, i want the music to be "I AM BUUURNING NOOO MY FLESH IS MELTING!"
Aka i dont think heroism fits here type of music
(My headcanon to how it should sound like but.. its debatable)
But its just. The whole vibe of the anime... it just doesnt do the manga justice is all? Its a great told story. But the anime i just dont think its it yknow?
Last edited: