Japan's Conspiracy (27-3)
Japan's Conspiracy (27-3)
=== harakiri aesthetics ===
We frequently hear the word "suicide bombing" in the news. Even on some TV programs, we occasionally hear this word used as a metaphor.
Japan has a unique philosophy called "
harakiri aesthetics". I thought that most Japanese and some pro-Japanese foreigners knew harakiri-related culture well.
But I have recently known that some Japanese and few foreigners understand this philosophy. So, let me explain about the philosophy a little, though it is too much to well-informed Japanese. For some time in the past, I was a typical "ideal Japanese". And I know so well how Japanese bureaucrats feel.
<< HYPOTHESIS >>
1. I think that Vice Defense Minister Takeaki Moriya is an excellent bureaucrat. If I had been him, I would have done the same thing. Mr. Moriya invented the knockabout in the Defense Ministry and the defense minister and the prime minister simply acted and spoke according to the scenario.
2. The scandal in the defense ministry had an impact on the Japanese politics. Prime Minister Shinzo Abe replaced the defense minister. Shortly after that, the Abe administration lost the Upper House election.
3. Once again, the leadership of the prime minister is questionable. Was the replacement of the defense minister a failure? Is Prime Minister's leadership in question? The government did need some scapegoat. Then, the vice defense minister, a person in the turmoil, got an idea of resignation.
4. The important difference between excellent bureaucrats and ordinary bureaucrats begins here. The outgoing vice defense minister thought of the way of resignation as his final, biggest and best contribution to the central government.
He was obsessed with how to boost the approval rating of the Abe administration. His conclusion was as follows.
He raises an ugly quarrel with the defense minister about his own dismissal. The minister is calm but cannot control the turmoil. Finally, Prime Minister Shinzo Abe intervenes and makes a courageous decision like a knight on white horse.
5. There have been quite a many similar cases, but now I remember only one case. It is a political knockabout over the replacement of the then Foreign Minister Makiko Tanaka in January 2002. As far as I know, this kind of knockabout began there.
(1) the facts about Ms. Tanaka's dismissal (See Note 1)
From April 2001 to January 2002, Tanaka was the first female foreign minister of Japan, but was fired from the cabinet after making remarks critical of Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi.
In September 2001, Ms. Tanaka inadvertently leaked classified information of the US to journalists just after the 9/11 attacks. But Mr. Koizumi failed to dismiss her and the scandal lingered.
In January 2002, Ms. Tanaka antagonized the then vice foreign minister over the participation of some NGOs to the Afghanistan Reconstruction Conference. She also quarreled with Mr. Suzuki, Chairman of the Lower House Committee on Rules and Administration.
On January 29th, 2002, Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi dismissed all the three persons all together.
From February 17th to 23rd, 2002, President Bush officially visited Japan, South Korea, and China. He had postponed this visit due to the 9/11 attacks (See Note 2).
(2) the aim of the knockabout replacement
After the 9/11, some people looked at Japan suspiciously. Mr. Bush finally decided to visit Japan. Japan wanted to avoid a serious debate. Japan tried to convince the Bush administration that there were no alternative prime minister other than Mr. Koizumi.
Mr. Koizumi replaced problematic politicians and plunged stock prices (See Note 3) and his own approval ratings just before President Bush's visit.
He emphasized a Japan in turmoil. But he absolutely had to avoid people's impression that he made an arrangement for Mr. Bush. So, he staged the political knockabout.
In Japan, performance of politicians and bureaucrats is always conducted following some scenarios. Those scenarios are made for making arrangement in favor of its counterpart and for letting people feel that Japan never bows to its counterpart. This is the root cause of the elusive politics.
6. the aim of the knockabout this time
This time, Defense Minister Yuriko Koike was called to the US and the head of the leading opposition party, the Democratic Party of Japan, Ichiro Ozawa, was called to the US Embassy in Japan.
The current situation is very similar to the situation in which the then foreign minister was replaced in 2002.
This time, former Defense Minister Fumio Kyuma was replaced with Yoriko Koike due to a slip of the tongue. The vice defense minister was replaced due to internal bickering.
This time again, arrangement was made in favor of the US and few people felt that Japan bowed to the US.
Stock prices fell again (See Note 4). The world would think that Japan is in turmoil and that it could really be a disaster to force Japan into a corner. Japan really hopes so.
----------(Note 1)----------------------------------------
Makiko Tanaka
Makiko Tanaka - Wikipedia
田中眞紀子 - Wikipedia
----------(Note 2)----------------------------------------
ニ但ニ陳?椎?ニ谷窶堙戸?督図ツ・窶堙銀?堙ァ窶堋「
(the intention of the US)
http://www.ne.jp/asahi/nd4m-asi/jiwen/thoughts/2004/22.html
窶愿コ窶怒窶堙債、ニ置ニ鍛ニ歎ニ停?ヲ窶堙姑椎?ニ鍛ニ致ツ・ニ探ツーニ池ニ湛窶堙娯?佚篠湘帚?堙??堋オ窶堋ゥ窶堙遺?堋ュツ、ニ但ニ陳?椎?ニ谷ナ?Oナ津ー窶堙娯?佚篠湘帚?堙??堋オ窶堙??堙戸?岩?冰窶堙??堋ッ窶堋キ窶堙ァ窶膿窶堋ヲ窶堙ァ窶堙ェ窶堙??堋「窶堙遺?堋「窶堋ア窶堙??堋ェ窶「窶壺?堋ォ窶卍、窶堙ィ窶堙俄?堙遺?堙≫?堋ス
(Japan was a mere country that deserved lip service for Mr. Bush. It was clear that Japan was never an American diplomatic counterpart.)
----------(Note 3)----------------------------------------
In January 2002, the Nikkei fell below the 10000 yen level.
Yahoo!ファイナンス - 株価やニュース、企業情報などを配信する投資・マネーの総合サイト
----------(Note 4)----------------------------------------
Nikkei shed 874 points on August 17, 2007.
Yahoo!ファイナンス - 株価やニュース、企業情報などを配信する投資・マネーの総合サイト
----------------------------------------------------------