I started liking Evanescence when Bring Me To Life came out (same as most other people who like them). Once I got the CD, however, it ended up being my least favorite song. I think Amy Lee has a very unique voice, and you can disagree all you want, but they had the potential to be the next Black Sabbath/Ozzy.
Unfortunatly, I do believe they will be dissolved very soon. I like them nonetheless, though. The choir in a lot of the songs is amazing, especially in Whisper and Everybody's Fool. the string arrangements are awesome, too.
Haunted and Tourniquet are definitely my favorites, and My Last Breath's lyrics remind me of Deo.