News Japan’s most crowded rush-hour trains

thomas

Unswerving cyclist
Admin
Joined
14 Mar 2002
Messages
21,050
Reaction score
18,903
Japan's annual government survey on train congestion has painted a stark picture of worsening rush-hour conditions in the country's three largest metropolitan areas—Tokyo, Osaka and Nagoya. The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism reported that Tokyo commuters in particular endured the most suffocating rides in 2024, with the capital's most overcrowded line running at more than 70% above its designed capacity.

Rush hour at JR Ueno Station in Tokyo's Taitō Ward

Photo taken on 18 May 1990 showing crowds of commuters packing the platform during rush hour at JR Ueno Station in Tokyo's Taitō Ward (Tanabe Kimiya via Mainichi).


The worst case was on the Nippori–Toneri Liner in Tokyo's Arakawa Ward, which during the morning rush reached an average congestion rate of 177%. Between 7:30 and 8:30 a.m., trains travelling from Akado-Shōgakkōmae Station to Nishi-Nippori Station carried 8,664 passengers in carriages built to hold just 4,887—leaving them crammed in at 77% over capacity.

Not far behind was the Tokyo Metro's Hibiya Line, where trains between Minowa and Iriya stations in Taitō Ward reached 163% capacity during the morning peak. The very same level of crowding was recorded on the JR Saikyō Line between Itabashi and Ikebukuro stations in Toshima Ward, marking it as the most overcrowded section of the East Japan Railway network.

The ministry explained that at around 150% capacity, passengers are usually able to stand without brushing shoulders, though crowding builds up around the doors. Once trains reach 180%, however, shoulders are pressed together and the squeeze at the doors becomes distinctly uncomfortable, with passengers left feeling the weight of the crush. On average, Tokyo's trains were running at 139% capacity, compared with 116% in Osaka and 126% in Nagoya. The figures highlight the continuing strain of urban commuting in Japan's largest cities, where the rail network remains the essential lifeline for millions of daily travellers.

Passengers feeling cramped on today's rush-hour trains might do well to think about conditions in the 1970s. Congestion rates in 1975, the earliest data available in the report, were around 200% in Japan's three major metropolitan areas, topping 220% in Tokyo. By today's ministry standards, that means passengers feeling considerably cramped with those near the doors unable to move.

 
And this, gents, is why I got my motorcycle license in Japan and started commuting by bike when I lived there years ago.
Although honestly my train commute wasn't all that bad. Just one line and a tight squeeze for just 3 minutes.
 
And that's why I prefer to take the bicycle when I need to go to Tokyo - despite the currently insane temperatures and humidity.
 
From personal experience, the trains in Tokyo certainly felt way more crowded than Osaka or Nagoya. I think the trains are less crowded in Osaka than Nagoya because there are more lines to chose from, even though Osaka is the bigger city. I used to take Hankyu for Osaka-Kobe-Kyoto cities, the subway for intra-Osaka, the bus intra-Kyoto, and Kintetsu to go to Nara or ocassionally Osaka-Nagoya. Of course there's also JR, and between Kobe and Osaka there was at least one more train company, but the name eludes me.

In Nagoya, by contrast, there is JR and there is Meitetsu. I never liked Meitetsu much for some reason. Of course, there's the subway as well.
 
Back
Top Bottom