This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

What I liked/disliked in the Troy movie

sadakoyamamura

Danshaku Sadako
Joined
30 Dec 2003
Messages
281
Reaction score
4
I really liked this Iliad inpired movie. Actually, this thread is more of 'liked'. So what if the story is not the same as the book? I mentioned 'inspired' right? Hollywood was never really 100% faithful to the 'written versions'...

Comments on the movie in general

- There were shots which really showed off the human form but they didn't look lewd or overly done.

- The costumes were really great. I wish I could wear one and show it off..


Short comments on some of the Cast

- Eric Bana's played well as his character as one who is torn between his people and his own family

- Peter O'Tool portrayed the part of King and a father who lost a child to an enemy so well.

- Brad Pitt. All I can say is 'What a hunk'.

- Orlando Bloom, didn't bloom in this movie. I think he lacked the maturity in required to play his character. I liked him better in The Lord of The Rings and Pirates of the Carribean.

Memorable Scenes:

- The first fight scene of Achilles.

- The 1000 ships sailing for Troy.

- The fight between Achilles and Hector.

- King Priam kissing the hand of his enemy and then asking for the body of Prince Hector.

That's it. Thanks for reading.

What do you think?
 
It looked like a huge pilot episode full of Xena extras, and despite I liked the Hector-Aquilles focus and the Eric Bana and Brad Pitt performances, there were too many distractions with secundary actors.

Favourite scenes? there are 3: The taking of the beach a-la Normandy style, the fight between Hector and Aquilles and the scene with Priam and Aquilles.

Overall, it's a good film, though not a great or an excellent one.

Btw, if anyone feels like reading the Iliad, translated into English, try this link: The Internet Classics Archive | The Iliad by Homer



The death of Patroclus:
 
:haihai:
There is a for me huge difference in the movie version from the book version. Even though I haven't read Iliad, I am familiar with Greek mythology and I would have loved Troy more if the gods and goddesses were mentioned or perhaps given their own scene to perhaps further explain why things happened the way they did-Thetis' scene doesn't even count since her name wasn't even mentioned. Take the case of my friend who left the movie house wondering why Achilles died of the arrow lodged to his heel...

I can only wish that the makers of this movie took into account the people who are not familiar with Iliad and mythology...

That said, I still believe it was a great movie despite its shortcomings.

Thank you for the link. I was really looking forward to reading the Iliad.
 
I thought "Troy" was pretty decent, not great, but good. Despite how great the world thinks Brad Pitt is, that was only the second movie I've ever seen him in, the other being the remake of "Ocean's Eleven", still, he did a good job as Achilles.

The fighting scenes were great, especially the heavyweight bout between Achilles and Hector, but Orlando Bloom got on my nerves as the skirt chasing pretty boy who started the whole shooting match by making off with Helen. And the beach scene with all those ships made the Normandy landings look like chump change!

Still, I'm surprised the movie only grossed 46 million in its opening week. Hell, "Van Helsing did better than that in its debut (54 mil) and it was panned out the wazoo. Not good considering Warner Bros spent nearly 200 million to make "Troy".
 
flashjeff said:
I thought "Troy" was pretty decent, not great, but good. Despite how great the world thinks Brad Pitt is, that was only the second movie I've ever seen him in, the other being the remake of "Ocean's Eleven", still, he did a good job as Achilles.

Try watching 7 (Brad is good but I think the one who portrayed the best role would be the villain Kevin Spacey... man he chilled me with his acting) and 7 years in Tibet...
 
there is a new bittorrent file for troy. created at 7/19/2004 9:52:11 AM. those who want it may contact hackerz at http://nacz.net i got it from him too.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…