Why do the martial arts hurt so much?

shotime77780

先輩
Joined
2 Aug 2004
Messages
87
Reaction score
1
Hi, ive been doing all sorts of martial arts all my life, taekwondo for 7 years, judo for 2 years, a little aikido, a little okinawan karate, and right now im into wrestling... ok i quit the martial arts a while ago because i wanted to do wrestling/track in shcool, but then yesterday i did like 6 hours of judo at a local studio.....bad idea my entire body is sore, i got scratches on my chest, bruises, oh wow... i never realized how much the martial arts hurts :( :(

share your pain
 
TwistedMac said:
it's all about how to best hurt eachother.. and you're surprised? :?

I disagree. I mean some martial arts schools still teach using actual combat between people but mostly now days thats only in tournaments and whatnot for safety's sake, and as our Grand Master had taught us, when using martial arts in real life its the art of self defense, get the other guy on the ground and run. So I can't say I agree with it being all about how to best hurt each other.
 
This post... really confuses me :/

You don't take as much martial arts as you say you have, then suddenly speak of "it hurting." Something is missing here.

(BTW, love the sig Akaisha lol)
 
Hmm that is true, that slipped my mind but yeah it is odd that one would now complain.. good thinking

(oh and thanx emoni ^_^ i do love toast!)
 
well ya your martial arts training isent supposed to beat ppl up its to defend yourself if you ever have to (god forbid) also while your training your doing all sorts of exercises no wonder your soar, especially if you havent trained in a while :p
 
Knives said:
well ya your martial arts training isent supposed to beat ppl up its to defend yourself if you ever have to

yeah, but setting all the bullshit aside, you do it to up your beating-people-up skills so when you get in that situation you'll look cool when you beat the other guy and your friends will still respect you.

if all people wanted was not to get hurt, there would be as many psychology classes as places to train how to raise your kick to reach a face or how to best slam someone into the floor.
 
Only a fool and someone so shallow would take martial arts for the sake of looking cool if in the situation. Martial arts(to my understanding) weren't originally intended to be used as so many use them(entertainment and self glory)
 
true, but they do it for those things in 99.9% of the cases.. most that claim to feel that there's some higher purpose were really just picked on earlier in his life and always wanted to be bigger, faster, stronger and cooler.

It's a fact and there's no need denying it.. it's just the way it is..

personally i've wanted to start doing some sort of gymnastics for a while.. something that'll teach me to do cool stuff that i can use to show off.. i have no wish to do something where all the guys i have to spar with just want to show off to the others.. i'll just get hurt...
 
Though I don't agree with the 99.9% overall I do agree that people somewhere in their reasoning take martial arts to be, as you said, bigger, faster, stronger, and cooler. I'm not denying it, I'm just saying. If that many people are shallow then so be it, its the fault of society for encouraging it.

Gymnastics are an art of balance mostly and flexibility both used most commonly in showing off, thats basically what gymnastics does. As for the part where you said "i have no wish to do something where all the guys i have to spar with just want to show off to the others.. i'll just get hurt..." I don't quite understand what you meant
 
Sadly, a vast majority of people do seem to be fairly shallow on their intentions of taking a martial arts class or self defense class. I've been involved in martial arts for only two years and have seen my share of garbage that goes on.

I take it not really for self defense as I do to protect other people around me. To do that of course you have to be able to defend yourself. I have yet to use it, and am quite proud of that. Oddly enough, "looking cool" can sometimes be to a great advantage self defense wise (not in the same way you guys meant above though). Just in classes, some people avoid sparing with others just because they "seem to know what they are doing." And while they can be quite good, their behavior tends to defend them more than their actual skill. You'd be surprise the effect of just walking straight has on how people will view you.

For me, it is Judo, and starting to look a bit into Aikido. Tried Kenpo, but didn't really like it. It depends on who you get as a teacher of course too (to a GREAT deal), and I've been lucky to have some very GOOD instructors, including Phil Porter.

I've been hurt, but not injured. There is a difference. Pain you just have to suffer through, maybe wait a few days or a week if you really strain something. It is just part of life, and you have to get through it. If you have taken martial arts this long, and are TRULY complaining about the pain (not just joking as you seem to be) then you must have missed a lot during the time you have been practicing.

Eitherway, I'm still confused to the point of this post! :D
 
akaisha said:
As for the part where you said "i have no wish to do something where all the guys i have to spar with just want to show off to the others.. i'll just get hurt..." I don't quite understand what you meant

i'll give you a scenario..
i go to a martial arts studio (any martial arts.. say i took up judo again.. that was one boring sport..)
i'm the new guy. no experience, no physical training.. i'm there for a few days and now i go spar against some guy that knows what he's doing and REALLY doesn't want to lose to the new guy, thus humiliating him... so he smacks me down really hard..

i'm allergic to pain.
 
Oh, now I get it.. but in my school they pair people up for sparing according to rank, not just pairing up people.
 
Twisted, any one who is that new shouldn't be sparing that early. I didn't start (and only done it a couple times) actual sparing till after a year's experience. Even then, when you spar, you are supposed to consider the person you are sparing against. If they are that intent on beating "the new guy" then you have the wrong people there.
 
Emoni said:
Twisted, any one who is that new shouldn't be sparing that early. I didn't start (and only done it a couple times) actual sparing till after a year's experience. Even then, when you spar, you are supposed to consider the person you are sparing against. If they are that intent on beating "the new guy" then you have the wrong people there.

that's what i've been saying!
i punched a guy in the guts after he had slammed me a few times in judo.. he didnt see that one comming..
 
Just spar with someone else or leave that school and find a better one. That sounds like a lousy place if you have to put up with that.
 
Why do the martial arts hurt so much? Lets break it down.
Martial:- Of, relating to, or suggestive of war.
Art:- The study of these activities

Originally martial arts were a supplement to weapons training, ie. weponless combat. Your goal in combat is to kill or incapacitate the enemy, which hurts alot.

Nowadays they are more sport related or self defence.

I did Shorinji Kempo for a while, which while hurting one hell of alot didnt leave you hurting afterwards. We'd do massage afterwards which kept the aches and pains away :D
 
Well, the only martial art I think I can recomend to twisted is one my friend was thinking of doing, and he is a black belt in Judo and Jujutsu. Look into クーキど。

It is a softer art form that is much more giving than others and involves no pain what-so-ever. I'm not kidding, no pain. Usually takes about 10 minutes of work and you have plenty to show for it. Invite some friends over and they will probably enjoy it as well.

Try it out, promise you that you'll like it.
 
.... Kuukidou? (I dont have the IME on this comp, im thinking air kanji ;))
Haven't heard of it, what its about? Pain is a relative thing, I can take you down with pain, or without pain. I just enjoy using obscure (ie. current favorite is fingernails) ways of making you do what I want.

If you want to learn self defence, take a self defence class. One or two sessions you'll be all set.
If you want to learn a martial art, set aside years for training and learning the philosiphies of that art.
 
Back
Top Bottom