Prefectural ranking: Ibaraki back at the bottom

[thomas]

The Brand Research Institute has released the results of its 2021 online survey regarding the allure and appeal of Japan's 47 prefectures.

The Top five:

1. Hokkaido
2. Kyoto
3. Okinawa
4. Tokyo
5. Osaka

The seven least attractive:

• Tochigi
• Yamaguchi
• Tokushima
• Gunma
• Saitama
• Saga
• Ibaraki

Ibaraki Prefecture's success in promoting its beauty and charms was short-lived. The prefecture returned to its familiar bottom-basement ranking in a survey this year of "attractive prefectures." For seven consecutive years until 2019, Ibaraki had ranked last among the nation's 47 prefectures for allure and appeal in the online survey conducted by Brand Research Institute, a consulting agency for regional brands based in Tokyo's Minato Ward. But after its promotional campaign, Ibaraki moved up to 42nd last year, relinquishing the "least attractive" title to neighboring Tochigi Prefecture in the northern Kanto region. The latest rankings, which were released on Oct. 9, put Ibaraki back in the bottom again. Tochigi climbed the chart to reach 41st.

Hokkaido kept its "most attractive" prefecture title for the 13th straight year, followed by Kyoto, Okinawa and Tokyo. Osaka Prefecture gained its highest-ever ranking, at fifth. Brand Research Institute asked respondents 89 questions in the survey conducted in July, including if they recognize each prefecture, if they had visited each prefecture, and if they are willing to visit each prefecture. About 35,000 people responded.

Ibaraki reclaims online title of ‘least attractive’ prefecture | The Asahi Shimbun: Breaking News, Japan News and Analysis

 

[thomas]

Tochigi Prefecture came 41st in the 2021 list announced by the Brand Research Institute Inc. on 9 October. Today's morning news reported that prefectural representatives (missed who exactly) consider suing the institute.

A statement from Tochigi Gov. Tomikazu Fukuda read, "Regardless of the results, we will work on strengthening our brand by refining local resources and proactively engaging with messaging in three strategic fields: selling prefectural products, attracting tourists, and encouraging people to settle here."
Tochigi Prefecture launched its own branding policies in 2016 as part of plans to raise its 35th place marked in 2015 to 25th in 2020. Instead, it was 46th in 2016 -- one above rock bottom. Despite tracking slightly higher at 43rd in 2017, 44th in 2018, and 43rd in 2019, it hit the 47th floor in 2020. When he heard Tochigi was last, Gov. Fukuda reportedly failed to hide his shock, saying, "I couldn't help shouting 'What?!'"

Tochigi breaks free of Japan's 'least attractive prefecture' title after 2020 shock result - The Mainichi

UTSUNOMIYA -- 2021's prefectural

mainichi.jp

 

[bentenmusume]

The seven least attractive:

• Tochigi
• Yamaguchi
• Tokushima
• Gunma
• Saitama
• Saga
• Ibaraki

The good thing about being a sake fan is that almost every prefecture in Japan has something to offer.
I can think of at least 2-3 incredible sake breweries from each of these seven prefectures, so I'd never in a million years think of them as "unattractive."

On a more serious note, I kind of sympathize with the governor's reaction, and I'd be questioning the point of releasing this sort of list, too, if I were in that position. I mean, for one thing, so much of it is out of their control, based on geographic factors, general stereotypes and preconceptions, etc. etc. Of course a landlocked, suburban/rural area north of Tokyo that isn't Tokyo (Gunma/Saitama/Tochigi/Ibaraki) is going to be seen as "less alluring" than, say, Okinawa or Kyoto. Also, I feel like it kind of becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. If "research" is telling people that Saitama objectively sucks, then it's only going to further cement that image.

 

[mdchachi]

The good thing about being a sake fan is that almost every prefecture in Japan has something to offer.
I can think of at least 2-3 incredible sake breweries from each of these seven prefectures, so I'd never in a million years think of them as "unattractive."

On a more serious note, I kind of sympathize with the governor's reaction, and I'd be questioning the point of releasing this sort of list, too, if I were in that position. I mean, for one thing, so much of it is out of their control, based on geographic factors, general stereotypes and preconceptions, etc. etc. Of course a landlocked, suburban/rural area north of Tokyo that isn't Tokyo (Gunma/Saitama/Tochigi/Ibaraki) is going to be seen as "less alluring" than, say, Okinawa or Kyoto. Also, I feel like it kind of becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. If "research" is telling people that Saitama objectively sucks, then it's only going to further cement that image.

Are you kidding? Do you really think it depends on these factors? The results are 100% in their control. I will bet you that if they hire the Brand Research Institute for "consulting" they will magically change their rankings substantially.

 

[thomas]

Ibaraki Prefecture climbed a notch in this year's ranking, leaving the last position to Saga Prefecture. For seven straight years until 2019, Ibaraki had ranked last in the attractiveness rankings. It moved to 42nd place in 2020, but the prefecture fell to the bottom again in 2021.

In the latest rankings, released on Oct. 8, Hokkaido retained its title as the "most attractive" prefecture for the 14th consecutive year, followed by Kyoto and Okinawa prefectures. Yoshihisa Takeshi, president of Anko no Yado Marumitsu, a ryokan inn in Kita-Ibaraki, was pleased to see the prefecture move out of last place. "The efforts by producers and tourism operators to spread the attractions of the prefecture could have yielded this result," he said. In June, managers at the inn started selling a lunch box containing monkfish liver and Ibaraki brand meat. It featured wrapping with the words, "Ibaraki, the least attractive prefecture," but the letters were upside down. "I took the ranking with a grain of salt, and made good use of our bottom position," Takeshi said.

Ibaraki casts off title of Japan’s ‘least attractive’ prefecture | The Asahi Shimbun: Breaking News, Japan News and Analysis

The results of the ranking are here:

地域ブランド調査2022　都道府県の魅力度等調査結果

地域ブランド調査2022の調査結果のうち、調査項目「魅力度」をはじめとする都道府県に関する結果の一部をご紹介いたします。　　　

news.tiiki.jp

 

[musicisgood]

I cycled through the east side of Ibaraki this summer. Lots of agriculture and foreign workers there. People were friendly with me at the convenience stores. Ibaraki actually gave me a sense of what Japan probably was like before WW2.
I recommend any cyclist and wild campers to tour Ibaraki. I think you'll enjoy the space, people and freedom that one feels in the air.

 

[thomas]

The annual "Prefectural Attractiveness Ranking," initiated in 2009, reached its 16th edition in 2024. While the competition for the top spot remains fierce, the battle for the bottom rank has also become a source of intrigue. This year, Ibaraki Prefecture, which held the last-place position in 2023, managed to climb two spots, surpassing Saitama Prefecture.

​

Hokkaido once again topped the list for the 16th consecutive year since the survey began. Following Hokkaido were Kyoto Prefecture in 2nd place and Okinawa Prefecture in 3rd, with well-known tourist destinations dominating the top spots. But the spotlight this year was on Ibaraki Prefecture, which managed to escape last place and rise two ranks. Ibaraki's charm is evident through local specialties like dried sweet potatoes, which account for 90% of Japan's production. Other local products, including natto, melons, and marine goods, highlighted the prefecture's uniqueness, with the surprising revelation that Ibaraki is Japan's top beer producer. One Saitama resident shared, "Saitama's a nice place with good safety and no disasters. We want to move up in the rankings, but we're okay with making a joke out of it, like with 'Tonde Saitama.'"

Ibaraki Escapes Last Place in Attractiveness Ranking

The

newsonjapan.com

Here's the complete prefectural ranking:

1. Hokkaido
2. Kyoto
3. Okinawa
4. Tokyo
5. Kanagawa
6. Fukuoka
7. Osaka
8. Nagano
9. Shizuoka
10. Ishikawa
11. Hyogo
12. Nagasaki
13. Miyagi
14. Nara
15. Chiba
16. Hiroshima
17. Kagoshima
18. Akita
19. Toyama
20. Aichi
21. Mie
22. Aomori
23. Oita
24. Miyazaki
25. Yamanashi
26. Kumamoto
27. Kagawa
28. Ehime
29. Wakayama
30. Niigata
31. Fukui
32. Okayama
33. Yamagata
34. Gifu
35. Iwate
36. Kochi
37. Fukushima
38. Shimane
39. Tochigi
40. Shiga
41. Gunma
42. Tokushima
43. Yamaguchi
44. Tottori
45. Ibaraki
46. Saitama
47. Saga