Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
henpai said:Hello. I've been trying to figure out this word for a little while... But I can't find anything useful on it. Can 地手 mean anything useful? The context I found it on reads just "キンパは地手です" ... If anyone could help me, I would be very thankful for the help! ^^
It was written like that. A truly mysterious phrase...Glenn said:Did you transcribe that from a spoken source, by any chance? That word doesn't seem to exist.
Where did you find it? It doesn't mean anything to me either. Could it be one of the "creative" words coined in anime and manga? Or, was it written by a private individual and not published work? In that case, it may be an error (by a non-native speaker), a typo or simple misconversion.henpai said:It was written like that. A truly mysterious phrase...![]()
I agree that we need more info. However, I'd just like to point out that native Japanese speakers are not immune from making mistakes in their native tongue, and I have seen many a mistake made by Japanese people. I'm sorry, but I hate it when people assume that native speakers are inherently infallible.epigene said:In that case, it may be an error (by a non-native speaker), a typo or simple misconversion.
In short, we need more info...![]()
A good guess...and sometimes but as always the reality is usually more complicated.J44xm said:How does one express necessity in nihongo? For example, "I need [noun]" or "I need to [verb]." For the former, I imagine the construction would be similar to "[noun] ga [word for needed]"; and for the latter, I imagine it'd be "[verb] koto ga [word for needed]." But I might be totally wrong.
Hmm. Well, first I'll do "hitsuyou" (必要):Elizabeth said:A good guess...and sometimes but as always the reality is usually more complicated.Try first finding some representative sentences in a dictionary under "hitsuyou" (need) or "iru" (require). I'll also expand on this as time allows.
J44xm said:Hmm. Well, first I'll do "hitsuyou" (必要):
私は勉強する必要があります。 (Watashi wa benkyou suru hitsuyou ga arimasu.)
食事制限は必要ですか。 (Shokujiseigen ha hitsuyou desu ka.)
Evidently, then, one of the forms would be "[abrupt statement] hitsuyou ga aru/arimasu," right? And the second form is that of its pseudo-adjective nature, correct? (Thus, "kore wa hitsuyou na enpitsu da" would be correct.) Is there a different between these forms?
Secondly, iru (要る):
まだお茶が要りますか。 (Mada ocha ga irimasu ka.)
偽りの友達なんて要らない。 (Itsuwari no tomodachi nante iranai.)
英語を学ぶには忍耐が要る。 (Eigo o manbu niwa nintai ga iru.)
Iru seems to follow the pattern I guessed more closely. Are there any low-level inflectional differences between "hitsuyou" and "iru" that I should know about? Do I have everything right? Thanks much!
I don't know if it's technically incorrect, but you don't generally hearJ44xm said:Hmm. Well, first I'll do "hitsuyou" (必要):
私は勉強する必要があります。 (Watashi wa benkyou suru hitsuyou ga arimasu.)
食事制限は必要ですか。 (Shokujiseigen ha hitsuyou desu ka.)
Evidently, then, one of the forms would be "[abrupt statement] hitsuyou ga aru/arimasu," right? And the second form is that of its pseudo-adjective nature, correct? (Thus, "kore wa hitsuyou na enpitsu da" would be correct.) Is there a different between these forms?
Iru can be used after 'wa' as well of course.Secondly, iru (要る):
まだお茶が要りますか。 (Mada ocha ga irimasu ka.)
偽りの友達なんて要らない。 (Itsuwari no tomodachi nante iranai.)
英語を学ぶには忍耐が要る。 (Eigo o manbu niwa nintai ga iru.)
One really important point is that Iranai or irimasen is much more common than either "hitsuyou wa nai" (too formal !) or the affirmative case, as Glenn implied above. It is used a lot when refusing something being offered (XXXha iranai desu) or for instance to indicate a word or particle isn't necessary in this sentence. Koko wa XXX wa irimasen.Iru seems to follow the pattern I guessed more closely. Are there any low-level inflectional differences between "hitsuyou" and "iru" that I should know about? Do I have everything right? Thanks much!
All right! It's always gratifying to see progress in one's self.Glenn said:It all looks good to me, but I'm not sure if there isn't a more natural way to say any of them.
Good grief, that's a lot of ways. Thanks for bringing them all to my attention, though. Being able to at least recognize these forms is important.Glenn said:By the way, as per your question of how to say "I need to verb," there are a few constructions that all involve a negative conditional and a "won't do" final verb. For example, for "I need to study":
I'll definitely keep that in mind. (Spontaneous practice example: "Boku wa taberu koto ga hitsuyou desu.")Elizabeth said:I don't know if it's technically incorrect, but you don't generally hear
[noun]ga hitsuyou ga...'. In this case, it would be hitsuyou desu.
After [noun]wa or the verb hitsuyou ga.... is fine, although maybe still not as common as hitsuyou desu. I'm the wrong one to ask about the desu/arimasu usages.![]()
Er, right, of course. ^_^Elizabeth said:Iru can be used after 'wa' as well of course.
I'll do that. Thanks for the pointer.Elizabeth said:In the affirmative case I'm not sure there is ever a situation that 'hitsuyou' isn't appropriate, and since 'irimasu' isn't nearly as casual or natural, you may want to stick more with the former for now.
Excellent! So then I should lean toward the "hitsuyou desu"/"irimasen" set, eh? Also, may I ask what the function of the "koko wa" is in this example? From my more literal reading, it reads "As for here, XXX isn't necessary." I'm just curious about the construction.Elizabeth said:One really important point is that Iranai or irimasen is much more common than either "hitsuyou wa nai" (too formal !) or the affrimative case, as Glenn implied above. It is used a lot when refusing something being offered (XXXha iranai desu) or for instance to indicate a word or particle isn't necessary in this sentence. Koko wa XXX wa irimasen.
J44xm said:Spontaneous practice example: "Boku wa taberu koto ga hitsuyou desu."
Elizabeth said:One really important point is that Iranai or irimasen is much more common than either "hitsuyou wa nai" (too formal !)
J44xm said:Excellent! So then I should lean toward the "hitsuyou desu"/"irimasen" set, eh? Also, may I ask what the function of the "koko wa" is in this example? From my more literal reading, it reads "As for here, XXX isn't necessary." I'm just curious about the construction.
Ditto. For the record, I was indeed going for the "I need to eat now!" meaning. I should have realized that the general sense would be the obvious way to understand this. I wonder if just adding "ima" might be sufficient in one sense.Glenn said:This sounds to me like you're saying that eating is necessary in a more general sense than "I need to eat (right now) because I'm starving." Whether or not it has that nuance I'm not sure, but if anyone can point me in the right direction I would appreciate it.![]()
I'll take special note. Many thanks!Glenn said:For verbs it's very common to use the patterns that I've given you. I'm sure you'll hear them enough if you pay attention, but I wanted to let you know anyway.
Sweet! I'll examine them closely. Arigatou.Glenn said:By the way, it's not as many as it seems to be right offhand if you just look at them a little. It's mostly just rearrangement, so if you just learn the first two the rest should be easily arrived at by plugging the right parts into the equation.
I think generally speaking it is slighter stiffer or more emphatic than the 'nakute (mo) ii' construction, probably corresponding to "there is no need" with "it isn't necessary" in English. In any case, I really shouldn't have mentioned it since AFAIK "hitsuyou (wa) arimsen/nai'' isn't formally analogous to iranai to irimasen in the context of the speaker refusing an offering. That would be 「必要じゃありません」I'm not sure how common this is, but I'm pretty sure I heard this in an anime: なんてやつだ。とどめを刺す必要はねえって言ったろ! It's not formal at all there, but it may be a dialectical thing. I think the one who said it (ドラゴンゴールゼットの孫悟空) speaks 宮城弁 (みやぎべん). Anyway, I take it to mean "there's no need to finish him" there.
By the way, を必要としているのではなくて is also a possibility for "don't need", but better to get the fundamentals under your feet first.Excellent! So then I should lean toward the "hitsuyou desu"/"irimasen" set, eh? Also, may I ask what the function of the "koko wa" is in this example? From my more literal reading, it reads "As for here, XXX isn't necessary." I'm just curious about the construction.