Thanks for the replies and for following along. It is a good think to express, to point out, to test, disect, and carefully reason and feel out all propositions, proposals, and thesis. This is not only what we are doing here, though, more than anything else we are strengthening the overall knowledge that is the educational process. It is, in one way more than just a scientific inquiry, (and is in no means to support 'Scientism' per se...a segment of scientific thought that I personally think little of) and yet, it is, in other ways, an actual exercise in knowing...which is what science means and is !
Chi65 said:
we should allow all points of view, in my opinion,
Yes, that is true as I had mentioned in the post just prior...given just below:
me said:
and I fully grant that each is fully entitled to an opinion, be it accurate or not
Hmmm.....I guess to each his own really.
Yes, that is true...(see above)
Please then tell me what I saw in my bedroom and what did the little girl see? I will say "ghost" because I have no other word for it.
Why would you refuse to use the word '
phantasma? You see, Goldiegirl, the matter is much deeper than just this surface that we are touching on here in this thread, but this subject of this thread can well be seen as
the key which can undo the lock on the door of further knowledge. There is so much I'd like to say, but such embedding would not be practical here. (I will PM you about that)
Goldiegirl said:
Ghosts, give me that hope.
In what state would you like that? In the mental state that you now are? Would you wish the same for the severe pedophile, who, as you had correctly pointed out is the way he is because of his brain state...which, as you also had correctly pointed out, will not and cannot be changed?
Would you guess that there is any reason to think there is a part of the living being which has no control over that living being whatsoever yet
IS that very living being, and is only 'normal' (whatever that may be) after that being dies?
I mean, otherwise the mentally challenged being is perpetually mentally challenged for all eternity? The homosexual being is homosexual for all eternity? And not a single person has offered any attempt to explain why it would be necessary, much less possible that clothing items...a perfectly human-designed/created thing...be ghosts too? Would we eventually have to be led, in order to maintain a whole, rather a hole, in our argument, that trees and rocks and yes, even the entire solar system has or is both physical and at the same time essentially a ghost?
Science--again, not Scientism--is a branch of knowledge gathering. There are some in the field, such as there will be in any field, fielded by human beings, who prove to be negative, bias, and greedy for fame and power to the extent that they can give 'pure science' a bad name in the public's eye from time to time. (and of course those who more so oppose science--say fundamentalistic religionists in America, for one example--use that to flame the fires of distrust for those who are less in the know)
I would suggest moving on then. I have presented my case in hard terms, and well enough to be understood, at least, by those who study and carefully think it through. As it stands, I can see that no one has answered to the challenge to show that what is known about the brain, what it is, how it works, and what that all means, is wrong or inaccurate. With that, therefore, I rest my case on that matter.
The spiritual realm--I'd like to look into this more deeply now. I would tend to think that the 'spiritual realm' may be something, as others have shown agreement with, that is to whatever degree (or even totally, maybe) physical, but is unknown.
One of the areas to look at might be parapsychology. I'll get to that a bit later.