Of course, I know...
I hope you realize that you are quoting yourself here?
Again, tell me what you learned the military brothel of yours at your country.
Comfort Women What do you think?
- Thread starter KirinMan
- Start date
Again, tell me what you learned the military brothel of yours at your country.
KirinMan
後輩
- 23 Jan 2007
- 2,173
- 68
- Thread starter
- #180
is it a religion?
Korean has
Caster, and "company" please read this post Post 172 , and you might understand a bit better where I am coming from.
Why can't you get beyond the "compensation" issue and discuss the point of acknowledgement that the "Comfort Women" issue is a fact of history?
Last edited:
Japan accepted the judgments of the trials and of other Allied War Crimes Courts both within and outside Japan. And, of course, Japan had already paid reparation to the countries concerned.
You will be surprised at the description of the Vietnam war in the fact_of_history loving Korean textbook. It does not tell anything about the brothel, rape or whatever you believe as war-crimes.
- 18 Jan 2005
- 11,682
- 3,643
If I do not misunderstand it,
This thread,
"Reliability of testimony of a Korean prostitute"
I thought so.
Only inspection of testimony of a Korean prostitute is necessary.
I thought that I argued about this inspection.
Therefore I pursue only its evidence.
Atrocious sex of the Japanese armed forces has no relation,
But you emphasize only a supposition.
Therefore it is strange.
This thread,
"Reliability of testimony of a Korean prostitute"
I thought so.
Only inspection of testimony of a Korean prostitute is necessary.
I thought that I argued about this inspection.
Therefore I pursue only its evidence.
Atrocious sex of the Japanese armed forces has no relation,
But you emphasize only a supposition.
Therefore it is strange.
KirinMan
後輩
- 23 Jan 2007
- 2,173
- 68
- Thread starter
- #183
Ok then come out here and tell everyone that you accept this part of Japanese history to be a fact. The "Comfort Women" was a fact, the stories of the "Comfort Women" are a fact, Japanese history should not be sterilized to create the image to the next and subsequent generations that this issue never occured.
And also that the current Japanese administration should not be attempting to rewrite accepted history, as you are a Japanese citizen as well.
As you wrote here Japan has accepted the fact that in it's history it is guilty in regards to the "Comfort Women" issue.
Remember one thing here, I do not blame you nor any currently living Japanese person that I know of for the atrocities committed during WWII including this "Comfort Women" issue. It is HISTORY, as I wrote before I have just as much reason to blame Japan for what happened, but I do not.
Again nothing to do with Japan and the WWII issue of "Comfort Women", again if you want to discuss that issue start another thread.
Methinks you misunderstand this thread, ifrom this quote here, it is not about Korea or the Korean "Comfort Women" alone, but about the overall issue of whether people here believe that Japan was culpable and guilty in regards to the overall "Comfort Women" issue.
It is not just dedicated to Koreans. You voted in the poll, I created it, it was not just about Korea, but all women forced and coerced into sexual service for the Japanese Imperial Military.
- 18 Jan 2005
- 11,682
- 3,643
Though I go astray with a theme,
In your logic,
The soldier of the United States Armed Forces raped a Japanese girl in Okinawa .
A rape is an order of the United States Armed Forces headquarters.
Because the reason is because a criminal belongs to the United States Armed Forces.
The United States Armed Forces are guilty.
This is your logic.
In your logic,
The soldier of the United States Armed Forces raped a Japanese girl in Okinawa .
A rape is an order of the United States Armed Forces headquarters.
Because the reason is because a criminal belongs to the United States Armed Forces.
The United States Armed Forces are guilty.
This is your logic.
KirinMan
後輩
- 23 Jan 2007
- 2,173
- 68
- Thread starter
- #188
bring a doccument
testimony. there are many thestimony that Japan did not
Beating around the bush again.........ahhh 窶敕ｦ窶堙ｪ窶堙ｩ,
"round and round we go where she stops nobody knows"
Good night folks.........thanks for another evening of :banghead:
Sleep well.
Obeika, no matter you want a fact you said. All Korean acitivists want is the apology and compensation.
About the compensaiton, it is the Korean govenment who should have given the money from Japan to the victims.
All I said to her was that you should count how many SDF members killed people or were killed in the post-war era, though she seemed not to agree with me.
About the compensaiton, it is the Korean govenment who should have given the money from Japan to the victims.
But unfortunately, the next phrase my Korean friend said (blamed) "it is currently living Japanese person who chose the current govenment".
All I said to her was that you should count how many SDF members killed people or were killed in the post-war era, though she seemed not to agree with me.
- 18 Jan 2005
- 11,682
- 3,643
I do not understand it for some reason,
The Korea government does not prove a crime.
However, they demand proof of a crime from the Japanese government.
In Korean society,
The accused should prove a crime.
It is mysterious society.
The Korea government does not prove a crime.
However, they demand proof of a crime from the Japanese government.
In Korean society,
The accused should prove a crime.
It is mysterious society.
hanachan
先輩
- 10 Mar 2007
- 265
- 16
D
diceke
Guest
yeah, close the thread. it's pointless.
Obeika ignores the posts of others when they make a valid point.
He only speaks, does not listen.
Obeika ignores the posts of others when they make a valid point.
He only speaks, does not listen.
- 28 Jul 2005
- 5,238
- 172
In due respect for our varying opinions, and the OP's obvious intent for this particular thread, on as equal a footing as I can percieve, I'd like to sugguest that the varying postions and opinions are most obviously set and to argue further, would probably lead to little benefit on either party's behalf.
I too, would once again urge care in not making personal attacks even if that were to mean a simple down playing of a person's ability or faculty. It might be good to take a breather before posting further?
窶堋ｨﾅ?ﾃｨ窶堋｢窶堋ｵ窶堙懌?堋ｷﾂ！ﾂ
KirinMan
後輩
- 23 Jan 2007
- 2,173
- 68
- Thread starter
- #197
Which is more "honorable" admitting to a past wrong and working towards a peaceful future or sweeping the accepted past and it's facts under the rug and lieing to future generations that it never occured.
I think you know the answer to that one.
I also add this from a post I made last night......"Post 172
Oh and btw, I have had the honor of meeting a Japanese woman that was forced into "sexual" service during WWII. It is very hard to not believe her and her accounts of the life she led, just to stay alive, while servicing the Japanese military men that came to her. Probably because of what I heard from her made me more than a little "unnerved" at the cavalier attitude that you and others posting here against this "Comfort Women" issue and the motive behind my question
"Do you think that all these women, making claims against the Japanese government and telling their stories about being comfort women are liars?"
Where is her "honor"?
Out of fairness to you, oh and this is my last response to you on this thread btw.
Take the time to read what I wrote, put aside your emotions , and stay on this topic and not bounce it around to America, Viet Nam or anywhere else.
Just Japan and it's part in the "Comfort Women" issue from WWII. Then you will know why I ignored certain portions of posts.
Then take a look in the mirror.
D
diceke
Guest
Are you serious? Take a close look at your posts. Who first said "America this, America that?" I didn't bring up all these topics about America. You did. I'm simply responding to you. You also brought up the topic about Germany, which, according to your logic, is irrelevant too. You are inconsistent and illogical. Take a look in the mirror, you ugly American!
- 21 May 2003
- 14,310
- 4,404
Think everything's been said that has value.
When a thread gets to the point it becomes a personal battleground and draws out so much anger, I feel it's time to close it.
Uncle Frank
When a thread gets to the point it becomes a personal battleground and draws out so much anger, I feel it's time to close it.
Uncle Frank
