About "Cry me a river."

round

後輩
Joined
29 Oct 2015
Messages
14
Reaction score
1
There is a song "Cry me a river"(1953).
How should I analyze this title grammatically?

My opinion:
Cry(Vt) me(Indirect Object) a river(Direct Object).
This sentence has a parallel construction to:
He shed me tears of joy.
=He shed tears of joy for me.

"A river" here is a metaphor for "tears like a river" or "a river of tears." And "cry" here is used as a transitive verb like:
-They lived a happy life.
-He died a miserable death.

But some say, "a river" here functions as an adverb like "Thanks a lot." and others say,"Cry me a river" is the same as "Cry [for] me a river. "For" was dropped due to some musical purpose/reason.

In dictionaries, I can find "cry" as a transitive verb.
However, I can only find an example sentence like:
He cried tears of joy.
I cannot find any example sentences with the SVOO construction.

Please let me hear your opinion regarding how I should grammatically analyze "Cry me a river."

Thank you in advance.
 
In my deep 60 second analysis, I find myself agreeing with you. It seems analogous to constructions like "Tell me a story," "Make me a cake" and "Shoot me a deer."
 
In my slightly-more-in-depth 65 second analysis: Cry in cry me a river is an imperative. The subject of "you" is implied. I think this is called the transitive imperative. I could be wrong. It could be both transitive and intransitive (as is hinted by this website below).
Verbs and Verbals
 
Not related but whats up with your profile pic? Is there some significance to superman holding the image?
 
Not related but whats up with your profile pic? Is there some significance to superman holding the image?

No meaning. That photo was taken at a photo studio. My wife chose that template, because our first son loved Superman.
 
Back
Top Bottom