あなたは俺が守る

jellofish

後輩
Joined
20 Feb 2010
Messages
64
Reaction score
0
あなたは俺が守る

I protect you

あなたは俺が分かる。

You understand me


Both sentense is あなたは俺が...

Why the first sentense does not mean "You project me"
 
Last edited:
Because the verb 守る doesn't take が as the object marker.

あなたは俺が好きだ/憎い/必要だ。
the subject: あなた, the object: 俺
 
Because the verb 守る doesn't take が as the object marker.

あなたは俺が好きだ/憎い/必要だ。
the subject: あなた, the object: 俺


すみません 鳥さん :(

Can you explain the difference of these 3 sentences :cry:
I know they all mean "I protect you"

俺は貴方を守る
俺が貴方を守る
俺が貴方は守る
 
The nuance difference can be understood as follows:

俺は貴方を守る I will protect you/ I protect you (as a habit/duty)
俺が貴方を守る I am the one who will protect you (and not another person who is going to protect you)
俺が貴方は守る As for you, I am the one who will protect you (and I don't know if I am going to protect other people). Notice that this type of sentence is often said as 貴方は俺が守る

When you study the language more, you will see that the particles can overlap in their functions.
 
The nuance difference can be understood as follows:
俺は貴方を守る I will protect you/ I protect you (as a habit/duty)
俺が貴方を守る I am the one who will protect you (and not another person who is going to protect you)
俺が貴方は守る As for you, I am the one who will protect you (and I don't know if I am going to protect other people). Notice that this type of sentence is often said as 貴方は俺が守る
When you study the language more, you will see that the particles can overlap in their functions.

Thank you @nhk9 😅

Very clear explanation:)

よく分かりました
 
Back
Top Bottom