This is broken up because he is banging his fist to emphasise each word. So is the normal sentence 俺たちが最高の学校一の強烈なチームだってことだ? I am having difficulty parsing the part 最高の学校一の.
4. おなじみの、正気とは思えない目の輝きだ。
What does とは思えない mean? It seems to me to have almost exactly the wrong meaning for the sentence...
3) And 学校一(の) means "number one (i.e. best) in the school", yes?
4) As far as I can gather, this should mean that the quality おなじみの正気 was gleaming in his eyes. I can't see what 思えない or 見えない have to do with this meaning.
Thanks Toritoribe, but I just have no clue what 思えない is doing in that sentence. Isn't that negative of 思える, meaning "not seem"? What connection does "not seeming" have with "It is usual/familiar for the speaker to see the insane gleam in his eyes"?