Some questions regarding the sentence structure

xawntan

後輩
Joined
25 Aug 2012
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
Hello all, I am new to this forum.
I'm staying in Japan for 3 months and I'm currently learning the Japanese grammar.
Being here for a month, I'm still unable to communicate with the Japanese T.T
I have a few questions regarding the sentence structure. It always confuses me when I want to construct a complex sentence with two clauses.


For Japanese sentences with 2 clauses (C1, C2), are they always read as (C2, C1) in English?


For example:
泣いた方がいい急ぎ過ぎてるかな
*It's from the song 曖昧.
C1 [泣いた方がいい] (would it be better to cry)
C2 [急ぎ過ぎてる]かな (I wonder if it is too hurry)
My translation: I wonder would it be better to be too hurry to cry


Another example:
この恋諦めて終わりにすればいいの
C1 [この恋諦めて] (Give up this love)
C2 [終わりにすればいいの] (Is it better to end)
My translation: Is it better to end and give up this love.
Am I right? :s

One more question- How to say this sentence in Japanese?
"Being here (in Japan) for a month, I'm still unable to communicate with the Japanese"
Any help would be appreciated. :-)
 
Last edited:
The first example isn't one sentence made of two clauses. That's two separate things run together.
 
The order of words/clauses are often changed from the normal one, especially in lyrics. For instance, you can say 終わりにすればいいの この恋を諦めて without changing the meaning. In fact, the normal order of a verse サヨナラなんて 出来ない このままでは is このままではサヨナラなんて出来ない. The key is the conjugation of verbs/adjectives like 諦めて, or particles like では.

How to say this sentence in Japanese?
"Being here (in Japan) for a month, I'm still unable to communicate with the Japanese"
What's your translation?
 
Thank you for your reply.
So it will still be the same meaning regardless of the order?
For example
いま、傘を買ってるコンビニに行ってる
いま、コンビニ行ってる傘を買ってる
Is that right?

Another question:
What does the まま in ままでは mean? I could not find its translation @@

My translation:
日本に一ヶ月いる、僕は日本人と話すできない
Not sure how to structure the first part. :/
 
Thank you for your reply.
So it will still be the same meaning regardless of the order?
For example
いま、傘を買ってるコンビニに行ってる
いま、コンビニ行ってる傘を買ってる
Is that right?
I said about compound sentences and complex sentences especially the latter ones, since you used the term "clause". Those are just two simple sentences as same as 泣いた方がいい 急ぎ過ぎてるかな, as Mike-san pointed out, but yes, those are basically the same in meaning.

Another question:
What does the まま in ままでは mean? I could not find its translation @@
まま - goo辞書

My translation:
日本に一ヶ月いる、僕は日本人と話すできない
Not sure how to structure the first part. :/
話すできない is completely wrong. Haven't you ever learned how to make the potential form of verbs?
 
Thank you!
Oh I forgot about that form, so it is日本に一ヶ月いる、僕は日本人と話せる。

ありがとうございます!

2
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Don't you know what 僕は日本人と話せる means? Shouldn't it be the negative form?

Not to mention about it doesn't always mean it is correct. "Being here (in Japan) for a month" implies the adversative conjunction like "Although I have been here", isn't it? What conjunction is used for it?
 
Back
Top Bottom