This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

What would happen if I got arrested in japan

GoldCoinLover

後輩
Joined
24 May 2004
Messages
1,046
Reaction score
12
Ok, I don't know any japanese. Barely enough to say tabemono for food and hello yes and no. What would happen if I went up to a chick on the streets of tokyo and started hitting her, beating her up. I'm sure I would get arrested. If I got arrested, what would it be like? What is the legal system like there? Is it different from the US? Would I go to court? Are the prisons better/worse than the US?

Just curious.
 
This has got to be one of the strangest questions I've read on Jref.

But it's as good as any.

I'm at work right now, so I can't spend much time going into detail. When I get home tonight I can check my resources and give you a detailed explaination. In the meantime I can assure you it wouldn't be nice. Most likely it would be expensive, trying, and you'd get deported, at best. Worst case senario you'd end up in prison for a few years.

Man, beating up girls? You could've thought of a more tasteful hypothetical situation....

 
My 2 female cousins got arrested there for working as a hostess or something in a bar ilegally. They had to stay in prison for 5 months. That's all I know.

They didn't get deported though, and they didn't have any money to pay it off so they went to jail. They said the jail was less harsh than the ones seem to be here. *shrugs*
 
Did your two cousins have a trial and were they convicted? It sounds to me more like they were locked up in pre-trial detention for that long and then released.
 
Perhaps then. ^^ I have no clue. Thats' all I know.
 
Dont, simple. Prison conditions in Japan are far far different to that of the US, just the fact you can be held for several weeks without legal representation is bad enough.
 
--------Here's some fun facts taken from the JET Handbook, 2003. (Published by CLAIR)

Over 90% of all Japanese convictions come from confessions. Nearly 100% of those are convicted.

You can be legally held for up to 20 days regardless of the crime. (The example given was someone arrested for possession of marijuana, 22 days from arrest to indictment.)



--------Now let's take a look at some of the fun things that happened to our fellow expat.

He was questioned an average of 9 hours a day for the first 17 days.

After every interrogation he was charged a $120.00 copy fee for his lawyer's records.

During that time he stayed in a six-tatami mat cell with 2 other people. He was eventually put in isolation, 24 hours daylight cell. On the bright side, he did get outside windows open for 30 minutes a day.

His bail was set at $20,000.00

After being convicted, he was deported.


------------------------------------------------------

All this for what would amount to a misdemeanor in the US. He estimated the total cost for this ordeal to be around $21,100.00. He was held in total for 27 days.
 
I had the misfortune of spending 2 weeks, courtesy of the Japanese Police, in a Japanese jail in Yokohama in 1987 for posession of a minute amount of hashish. It's quite a long story and I will post it shortly in a couple of parts.

Let me tell you one thing, it is not a pleasent experience. Once arrested you have absolutely no rights whatsoever. You are guilty until proven innocent, you cannot make a phone call or let anyone know where you are until you are indicted, which can be up 30 days, you cannot post bail until indicted or you are realeased. You cannot even have a lawyer present at questioning!

I was not abused by either the police, detectives, or my cell mate, nor did they treat me harshly as long as you followed the rules. The questioning is intense and may be a couple of times a day for a minimum of an hour at a time.

When I was indicted I was allowed to post bail. 3,000,000yen (US$30,000) at 10%. My lawyer cost me about 300,000yen (US$3,000) Trial was some 7 months later. If you can't post bail of course you will spend your time in jail until the trial.

You will go to court if indicted and will face one judge or, in my case, a panel of three judges. If convicted you may receive prison time or probation. It all depends on how contrite you are. If you are a single foreigner with no relations in Japan you will be deported and may be banned from Japan for at least 5-10 years. In my case, I had a Japanese wife and was not deported or banned although I could have been. I guess my sincere, honest apology convinced the judges.

Prison I can't say as I never went. I received 3 years probation. The jail on the other hand was not bad from what I heard in the states. 3 hots a day. Up at 6am in bed by 9pm. Allowed out of cell 3 times/day for smoking and stretching. Very, very boring. No abuse from the guards whatsoever. It was not a pleasent experience and is one I will never experience again.

In the end you don't want to experience it. Trust me.
 
Two points:

1. The maximum police/prosecutor detention is 23 days, not 30. (At least that's the figure now, no idea what it was back then.

2. One very large difference between Japanese prison and Japanese pre-conviction detention centers is that Japanese prisons have forced labor. And harsh conditions.
 
2. One very large difference between Japanese prison and Japanese pre-conviction detention centers is that Japanese prisons have forced labor. And harsh conditions.


Sweet Jebus! Speaking from experience, mike?
 
No, but I've done considerable reading of Japanese books on the topic. I can recommend titles if anyone is seriously interested.
 
No, but I've done considerable reading of Japanese books on the topic. I can recommend titles if anyone is seriously interested.

I am, it would be great if you could recommend some. Good practice and an interesting subject. Plus, it would coincide nicely with the "Books that Changed my Life" thread.....

 
Thank you.

Keimusho no Okite looks promising. Think I could pick this up at the local bookstore in Osaka? Or is this an amazon.com buy?
 
One other thing to note when you're in detention: You have to request a translator/English-speaking guard be present for your visiting hours to speak anything other than Japanese. I visited a friend that was there (standard 20 or so days until he saw the judge... another month on top of that and eventually bail and probation). They make you fill out a form, pointing out you have to speak Japanese b/c otherwise the guard in there with you won't understand.

This was also a drug-related incident. Worth noting. He was not deported, but put on probation. Fed-up with the system (while he knows he screwed up, he had actually pulled a lot of small Japanese businesses out of the red, which they didn't care about) he left. Wanting to come back to visit his inlaws, was stopped at Narita.

EDIT:
Mike, was this a woman? Excellent picture either way.
 
Last edited:
That was a woman.
 
Woah Japan sounds realy harsh, what would they do if they caught you drinking underage. And is the drinking age definatly 20, someone said it was 21 but I'm pretty sure that its 20?
 
GaijinPunch said:
One other thing to note when you're in detention: You have to request a translator/English-speaking guard be present for your visiting hours to speak anything other than Japanese.

I want to be one of those translators for a job...anyone know a website to learn more?
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…