A few things... I rewrote this... I can't figure out how to put all this.
A) I think it's a bit crass to simply label someone you know as 'not hot' read ugly, we don't care what your beauty standards are... you don't have to impress us with your tastes in women.
B) I really don't think that the two girls, especially the one you label as the most beautiful woman you've met, are full-blood Japanese... Maybe I'm nit-picking... but I think if you say you like Japanese women, they might as well come from Japan...
I don't know this to be true, it's a guess, because (baring one particular part of Japan people are well aware of), Japanese do not have these types of facial structures, and they certainly don't have the types of long and slender noses that these women do...
Correct me if I am wrong, but I'm going to wager a bet that you live in Hawaii, and that these two girls on either side of the middle are half-Japanese American highschool students.
Am I right?