Pretty vague response. "Good percentage". What's that? 15% 32% 68% At least give us a ballpark figure of what you "believe".I believe a good percentage of Japanese in some specific fields do have practical-creativity & applied innovativeness
No, I don't think so, and neither do the pundits. Otherwise we wouldn't be having this discussion. Stick to the topic, please.same for other nations or cultures in this world,don't you think ?
Nope. Not like it at all. I really really really hope you read the links provided here, otherwise you people just spout off unjustified opinions based on hearsay. Read this. Education in Japan EDUCATION IN JAPANI am no expert on the education system in Japan, and have never actually seen it. But, based on what i'm told about it, i feel that perhaps the problem with Japan's education system is that it's too much like America's
And what do you think that may be?But no, I do not think that Japanese children are lacking in critical thinking, at least not in the ways the Japanese value.
"Often"?Western critical thinking can be rude and often leads to circular logic in individuals without knowledge in a topic field.
Are you referring only to the college entrance exams? You need to learn a few things.Perhaps make examinations a bit easier, though?
And what do you think that may be?
"Often"?
Are you referring only to the college entrance exams? You need to learn a few things.
1. With the declining population here, by 2050, the acceptance rate for universities will be 100%, which means no matter what exam they take (if they take any at all), they will be accepted.
2. My parenthetical statement above deserves explanation. Schools on the escalator system (sister HS/sister university) don't require entrance exams of their HS graduates. I used to work for one.
3. Universities (and HS) have entrance exams, yes, but not all the time. Some students get in on what is called a "recommendation". And, entrance exams vary in their difficulty: my own university has 3 types, so did my HS.
4. If you are not referring only to entrance exams, here's a little diddy for ya. My previous HS (a fairly prestigious private one) had plenty of the following cases. Japanese teacher gives English test. Student(s) fails. Student gets same exact test and a chance to retake it...6 more times! Still fails, but passes the course. I could cite other examples far worse.
As in often, it certainly depends on who you associate with, or which type of context (formal or informal), but I guess I mean that Americans strong in critical thinking are known to sometimes be too expressive in their views, pushy even.
I'm slightly at a loss of where this topic is heading. Are we cross comparing American Education vs. Japanese education? Critical thinking vs. Creativity? Whether critical thinking gets you a so called "real job" or not? What critical thinking means to the Japanese? The Americans? I feel like having a say...but there are just so many things being thrown around I feel a bit lost...
Needless to say, the different career path from the US has nothing to do with the critical thinking, just another rat race after all.
(12:01:48 PM) NAME REMOVED: i need to know if the motherboard of a computer can handle the ram you want to put in it is there anything special that is needed to be done to install it?
(12:02:24 PM) NAME REMOVED: this is on a vista machine
As an american,I can tell you there isn't much "critical thinking" in this country,even from college students.
We are taught alot of opinionated BS.
We're taught to speak out our mind, even when we know or don't know it's wrong.
On the Japanese critical thinking comment, I meant that it takes critical thinking to discern all the subtle meanings in Japanese speech and etiquette, all the double entendres. I'd assume that part of the culture blocks out certain aspects of critical thinking for the Japanese... like the perservere mentality taught to children.
As in often, it certainly depends on who you associate with, or which type of context (formal or informal), but I guess I mean that Americans strong in critical thinking are known to sometimes be too expressive in their views, pushy even.
I was, but I was also aware of the other exams. And yes, everyone can stand to learn a few things, and I thank you for educating me. Most of my research on the Japanese school system is regrettably about 10 years out of date by now, forgive me.
As for the university entrance, I bet a lot of people shoot for the more prestigous schools because they don't want to end up as sararimen.
however, it ihas nothing to do with creatinity.I simply see a difference in degree, and Japan (as well as other Asian nations) seems to have a much lower focus and emphasis on critical thinking than the United States, at least at a college level and a bit prior to that too.
Even the owners of America want obedient citizens not a population has critical thinking.
* Comedian George Carlin on " education in America "
however, it ihas nothing to do with creatinity.
If there are desire and interest in that.., they would have that naturaly.
Japan is an otaku country. it is not means only anime nerd or hentai geek.
i think many various otakus made a creativity that they are interested in..
however, it ihas nothing to do with creatinity.
If there are desire and interest in that.., they would have that naturaly.
Japan is an otaku country. it is not means only anime nerd or hentai geek.
i think many various otakus made a creativity that they are interested in..
is it just your experience?As for critical thinking, I think it is partly a mindset as well. I've learned to be more "critical" thanks to certain college teachers who didn't just have me read a book and write about it, but question who wrote it, why, compare and criticize what was in it to other readings and question the strength of their evidence and presentation. I have never seen in any Japanese class this being done in any manner. This is one example and while I do believe that it occurs in a few classes at least, I don't think it is naturally considered. The same goes with classes in Korea and China at colleges I have witnessed as well as students I have spoken with
you are so ridiculous....Ummm... Huh?
As for critical thinking, I think it is partly a mindset as well. I've learned to be more "critical" thanks to certain college teachers who didn't just have me read a book and write about it, but question who wrote it, why, compare and criticize what was in it to other readings and question the strength of their evidence and presentation. I have never seen in any Japanese class this being done in any manner. This is one example and while I do believe that it occurs in a few classes at least, I don't think it is naturally considered. The same goes with classes in Korea and China at colleges I have witnessed as well as students I have spoken with
you are so ridiculous....
it is a common way in everywhere...
I think you need a critical thinking based on more knowledges about Japanese education at first
did you investigate it? if you didnt it is just your masturbation how you got superiority education.
of course, there is a ploblem in Japanese education
Considering your rude, insulting, and accusatory behavior, I'm not sure why I, or other posters, continue to respond. Maybe it is just too late for me to rationally decide not to