macadamia_cocoa
Virgin Islands Girl
- 15 Feb 2007
- 19
- 1
I don't think it's as much as a problem as everyone is making it out to be. Westernization and traditionalism can co-exist easily.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Actually I don't see how Turkey is torn apart. At least I know a lot of Turkish people who prefer living in modern Istanbul but in the traditional turkgerman quarters of Berlin or the Ruhrarea. And Turkey has been a modern state since Atatテシrk's reform anyways, hasn't it?
I don't think it's as much as a problem as everyone is making it out to be. Westernization and traditionalism can co-exist easily.
1) You live in a country that has been systematically denying a genocide. You could have been indoctrinated from birth, for all I know. I'd like to believe that I live in a country in which an open and honest discussion about subjects like these is available. Most people and scientist in western countries, Russia and even a growing number of people in your country believe that this was indeed genocide.
2) So you agree that Turkey has a problem when is comes to Human Rights?
3)This is the first time I've read anyting about a massacre of Turks by the EOKA. The invasion of parts of Cyprus by Turkey was a cunning way to gain territory. Claiming to uphold the Treaty of Guarantee.
Sorry, I will skip completedly the episode of Turko-Armenian history, and return to the original theme.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
I will separate the terms "Modernization" from "Westernization".
Both Turkey and Japan are both "modernizing" since more than a Century ago... and I think is good...
Now, "Westernization" is a term with trick... who says if one country is "western" or not?
Look at the shameful game regarding the entrance of Turkey in Europe... speaking at convenience in terms of race and religion ("Europe as Christian Civilization...") when they so fit.
If well the material adventages in entering the E.U. cannot be overlooked... I feel like I want to tell Turkey... "say to them: Go to hell!... There is a lot of space for Turkey interests in Central Asia".
I repeat: It is a term with trick... they say that you are "westernized" if you, due your own work and whatever your culture, are rich and successful. On the other hand, Christian people like Russians will never become "westernized" until Corporations and polititians in rich countries says so.
See all that garbage about "Japan as a Westen Country"... if you are rich and successful, and well integrated in World Economy, doesn't matter that your deep history has nothing to do with a Western European, Greek-Roman, Judeo-Christian, Humanistic, etcetera, supposed cultural background that again, supposedly form the core of Western Civilization.
Why we don't simple say "You are in the club of economicaly successful countries".
Soon, even China one day may be "a Westen country".
I believe that such a term "Westernization" leads only to confusion, and some negative effects in traditional cultures. Maybe not everything traditional everywhere is desirable... but some things that have matured during centuries in a given place, should not be so easily changed for a bottle of Coke and a shirt with Mike Jordan.
I am myself, not "Westernized" and don't want to be, not now and probably not never.
Regards.
In the case of Japan, this manifests itself by saying they should have a non-Western mentality, anti-Western bias and general hostility to foreigners....all of which are basically true. Not by design as much as by a deep seated awareness of and pride in the uniqueness, often misplaced, of their own culture.They should... and in fact, as an example, Japan did in my opinion wonders regarding that. But not everyone has that success.
Regards.
It seems to that most Japanese are more materialistic than many Westerners.The desire for American products and lifestyle but strong reservations about importing its government and the individualism or materialism of its people. ☝
Yeah, everyone has to be the same so they have to have everything their friends have. But still I think social relationships are hugely more important to the well-being of most Japanese compared to Americans (and some Europeans) which is a very good thing imo. You can't say they'll never be a Western country though....It seems to that most Japanese are more materialistic than many Westerners.
Probably you are right about the social relations.Yeah, everyone has to be the same so they have to have everything their friends have. But still I think social relationships are hugely more important to the well-being of most Japanese compared to Americans (and some Europeans) which is a very good thing imo. You can't say they'll never be a Western country though....
You can't say that so quickly or flatly.Probably you are right about the social relations.
And yes, you're certainly right that I can't say never because noone knows for sure. But Japan becoming a genuine Western country is nonetheless pretty improbable.
And I will not comment on Jiyuu's caricature of the Armenia incident, for the same reason I do not debate with Holocaust deniers: I don't debate with liars.
I guess there's a definition problem... Westernization as I define it includes (but is not limited to) foremostly the cultural adoption of Western values and so forth. Nevertheless even very Westernized countries may never become 'Western' as such, because for me these countries have to derive from the West. (So, unless all or the vast majority of the native Japanese are either killed off or driven out, Japan won't become a Western country...).You can't say that so quickly or flatly.In terms of political and business governance, there is grass-root democratic opposition to the ruling elites of the post war that has been born just since the economic collapse of the early 1990's. Opinionmongering, public debate, plus a greater sense of personal freedom and outspokenness are becoming more and more accepted as the norm if not easily embraced. There will always be kimonos and caligraphy but the mentality is slowly becoming ever more similar to a so-called "Western" mindset or outlook on life.
Same goes for you.Meh..Fine buddy. Just don't over-dramatize the lies you have ben convinced to
As am I to Holocaust and other genocide deniers.I am well accustomed to this degree of Armenian Genocide fanaticism
I guess Holocaust deniers would say the same.If only it was real so that I'd not hesitate to apologize.
Agreed.Whatever, let's leave it here.
I guess Holocaust deniers would say the same.
According to you every nation will be called 'Western' as soon as they reach a certain amount of wealth, regardless of cultural background .
Well, that's as far as I am concerned wrong. Westernization is the adoption of Western values and Western culture.
Therefore Japan is imho not part of the West and will never be. Neither will China.
Yeah, I guess I got that wrong.What I wanted to say, is exactly the other way around. Read again... or correct me if my idea was expressed so confusedly that really not only you but everyone that read it will fail to understand what I wanted to express.
I've pointed out that there's a difference between "Western country" and "Westernized country" =)"Well, that's as far as I am concerned wrong. Westernization is the adoption of Western values and Western culture."
This is a mild definition that actually may work somehow. But there is also the "strong" version, like... "Therefore Japan is imho not part of the West and will never be. Neither will China."
What is it then?In a positive sense... having institutions and values that do not conflict with what we positively assume is "Westerness" (otherwise, Japanse culture will not will be so highly regarded in the West)... but its attractiveness and "Enlightment", so to speak, is not in the larger part results of what Westerners did or offered, as they maybe "Eurocentrically" maight think.
Sorry, Latin America is most commonly translated as "Süd-Amerika" in German which means literally "South America", of course "Latein-Amerika" exists as well but it is not used as often.Regarding of what you said about this other area, "Latin America" ()...
Latin culture not Western? I fail to see the logic behind there... Roman and therefore 'Latin' culture is an integral part of Western culture.well, here is an example of what I said about the recent hypocrecy of the term "Westernization".... look for example the books of Samuel Huntington (he theaches racism in Harvard)... saying that Latin America has a "Latin culture", and therefore it is not "Western" ().
(I wonder if Huntington has admirers in Argentina).
In reality, his racist thinking makes no sense, and only reached notoriety for the events since 2001.
Almost no term is neutral in that regard. And as you see in this thread 'Western' is per se neither positive nor negative. It depends on the individual whether he or she likes it or not.I wonder if there if we come up with a definition of "Westerness" that is honest and not influenced by partial or politically motivated.
Sorry, Latin America is most commonly translated as "Süd-Amerika" in German which means literally "South America", of course "Latein-Amerika" exists as well but it is not used as often... Latin culture not Western? I fail to see the logic behind there... Roman and therefore 'Latin' culture is an integral part of Western culture.
when you say Westernization, do you mean that as "Americanization" or "Europeanization" or a mix of the two?
Could someone please educate me to as how genocide or ethnic problems in Turkey have anything to do with "westernization" of Japan?
As noted earlier, there is often confusion about what Westernization really is versus disliking rampant mass consumerism of Western (or other) goods. Of course, we could blame Western culture for introducing mass consumerism, but it is hardly a private preserve of Western countries now.
As to Western values, even here it is not always clear, but of course democracy, and equal rights were introduced, even though these don't exist in their pure forms in any country today. Some other values are difficult to evaluate as Western as Western countries differ in some values and aspects. France is different from England, which is different from America. It's difficult to isolate and identify what those values are.
Latin culture not Western? I fail to see the logic behind there... Roman and therefore 'Latin' culture is an integral part of Western culture.
Sirius2B said:(I wonder if Huntington has admirers in Argentina ).
Like gaijinalways wrote here whose country are you going to use as the definitive western country or western values.
I would like to know what a Japanese person thinks about this, or who they think of when they think about "seiyo-jin"
Das Wetter ist zu mild für diese Jahreszeit, morgens häufiger Nebel aber dafür scheint mittags die Sonne. Achja, ich bin auch der Auffassung, dass Duzen angebrachter ist als Siezen, zumindest in Foren wie diesen. ^^Ja, ich weiss schon... wie ist das Wetter im Hesse?
Entschuldigen Sie...
I see.the truth is that I am just arriving from very confrontative forums and most of what I say, I say with "puns" and irony... and maybe a little bitterness... it will take a little (very little) to adjust to this more or less easy going and serious forum.
I say and then repeated "Latin" America, precisely to emphasize that there is "ignorant academics" (another irony!), that fail to see than Latin (understood as Roman) culture is one of the Roots of what is ment historicaly as "Western".
Danke, gleichfalls. Die Flagge bei meinem Avatar ist einfach nur die Landesflagge des Bundeslandes Hessen. Die Farbkombination ist aber auf der Welt relativ beliebt, z.B. hat Polen dieselben Farben nur umgekehrt und die Indonesische Flagge ist sogar identisch.Haben Sie ein schoenen Tag... aber ich will wissen uber die Fahne bei deine Avatar... die habe ich vorher geshen ich glaube, aber jetzt erkenne ich sie nicht.
So, how broad is "white" or "caucasian" defined by you? Does it include Arabs? Semites? Hispanics? Slavs? Or is it limited to Aryans?My point is first one has to define what "westernization" is for it to be compared to Japan or any other "non-western" country. I don't want to come across racially biased here, but for lack of a better term in my mind at least, when many people think of western countrIes and western culture they think of "white" or should I say "caucasian" culture.
Das Wetter ist zu mild für diese Jahreszeit, morgens häufiger Nebel aber dafür scheint mittags die Sonne. Achja, ich bin auch der Auffassung, dass Duzen angebrachter ist als Siezen, zumindest in Foren wie diesen. ^^
Danke, gleichfalls. Die Flagge bei meinem Avatar ist einfach nur die Landesflagge des Bundeslandes Hessen. Die Farbkombination ist aber auf der Welt relativ beliebt, z.B. hat Polen dieselben Farben nur umgekehrt und die Indonesische Flagge ist sogar identisch.
I mean nordic people (It's like with the swatiska, even though the term "aryan" and the swatiska had originally other meanings, today they are most commonly associated with the white people and the nazis, respectively.)do we mean people of "nordlich" appeariance... or we are meaning Iranians or high castes in India??
Oh well... The USA have the brightest people in the world but also the dumbest. [They also got the fittest people in the world and the fattest! A land of contrasts and superlatives.] Therefore it's surprising that those who think of southern Germans being swarthy even know that Switzerland, France and Germany are all European...And for US Elites (that supposely do not exist), the children should marry, if no option, with "White" European people... for that "French and Germans of the South are swarthy... but not the Swiss!!"...
That's why they're called "hispanics"Hispanics (specially Mexicans) in the USA cannot be white, not even for the Blacks, although they come in a variety of colors too.![]()
I doubt that, Jews could never be real Nazis unless they are suicidal and kill themselves.Oh!! And I forget that in the USA (to close the subjetct) Jews could be Nazis too... although the "bad Nazis" want to kick them out their organizations in recent times.
Nah, I guess that's too much of a generalization, there are always xenophobic morons who judge others based on skin-color or descent and don't care about wealth.Arabs also come in a variety of colors... their fate and treatment they receive, depends more or less of $$$$... be it in Marseille or New York.
Regards.
Gern geschehen =).Ja, vielen dank für die Auskunft...