Adding Extra Information

Tomii515

やった~!
Joined
16 Feb 2006
Messages
1,206
Reaction score
21
Hello everyone :)

So I'm wondering how to make a sentence adding unnecessary or extra information. For example:

I just saw a monkey. + Monkeys are my favorite animals = I just saw a monkey, (which is my favorite animal.)

僕は猿を見たところです。 + 猿は一番好きな動物で す。 = ?

I'll take a guess, but I'm not sure if it'll be right:

僕は(一番好きな動物だ)猿を見たところです。

I'm sure it isn't right, but who knows? Not me :D

よろしくお願いします
 
My gut reaction would be to say

僕は一番すきな動物の猿を見たばかりです。

But of course I am probably wrong.
 
Hello everyone :)
So I'm wondering how to make a sentence adding unnecessary or extra information. For example:
I just saw a monkey. + Monkeys are my favorite animals = I just saw a monkey, (which is my favorite animal.)
僕は猿を見たところです。 + 猿は一番好きな動物です。 = ?
I'll take a guess, but I'm not sure if it'll be right:
僕は(一番好きな動物だ)猿を見たところです。
I'm sure it isn't right, but who knows? Not me :D
よろしくお願いします
I haven't been actively studying much lately either. lol.

But how about (僕の)一番好きな動物である猿 >>>If 猿 is the subject or topic of the sentence...:p
 
Last edited:
What Tomii-san was talking about maybe be the non-restrictive relative pronoun, by any chance? If so, I would say ちょうど今猿を見ました。(ちなみに猿は僕が一番好き な動物なんですが。)
 
Yeah, it looks like the non-restrictive relative pronoun to me too. I think like Toritoribe suggested, it's best to split them up and use ちなみに, which is like "incidentally". Since Japanese doesn't distinguish between restrictive and non-restrictive relative clauses, to be clear about what you mean you'd have to split them up.
 
Tomii --

ちょうど今猿を見ました。(ちなみに猿は僕が一番好きな動物なんですが。)
I've just seen a monkey, which is my favorite animal.

(僕の)一番好きな動物である猿をちょうど今見ました。
I've just seen a monkey which is my favorite animal.


I wasn't exactly sure what he meant so just corrected from the standpoint of だ to である.

But the latter I guess is kind of awkward to put in context. Maybe in response to a question like
"Haven't you seen your favorite animal lately" !??? :P
 
Back
Top Bottom