無意識に / もらいます / いつまでに何... / い、いっつも...

eeky

先輩
Joined
8 Jun 2010
Messages
2,431
Reaction score
22
Hiya,

1. This is part of an explanation of the word つい:

無意識にする/してはいけないと思っていてもそれをしてしまう場合によく使う。

Initially I assumed this was going to mean something like "Often used when someone doesn't consciously intend to do something but ends up doing it anyway."

However, I can't actually seem to get that meaning out of it. In particular, I'm uncertain about how 無意識に fits or what it modifies. To get the expected meaning, I want it to modify それをして, but it seems to actually modify either する/して or 思っていて. I suppose modifying 思っていて makes more sense, but it still doesn't seem exactly right to me. How does this part of the sentence work?


2. これから作文を書いてもらいます。

I'm not sure what situation this would be said in, or whether it's an instruction, or statement, or what (there's no further context; it's an isolated example sentence). Could it be like a teacher saying "Now I want you to write an essay for me"?


2. These are instructions for a writing exercise:

いつまでに何をしなければならないか書いてみましょう。

The combination いつまでに何...か confuses me a little. Could this mean "Write about what you have to do and when you have to do it by"?


3. い、いっつも食べ物で懐柔されるとは、限りませんからねっ。

Translation given: "Don't think you'll always be able to placate me with food!"

a) What is the い at the start? Just an exclamation? [Edit: or maybe a stutter?]

b) Is いっつも a more emphatic version of いつも?

c) How does 限りません, which seems to be referring to absence of limit, result in a meaning like "Don't think you'll be able to ..."?
 
1) 無意識にする is modifying 場合.

2) That's how I interpreted it.

3) The い at the beginning is like a stutter, yes, and いっつも is an emphatic version of いつも.

とは限らない is a set expression meaning something like "not limited to...", so "not always" is a good translation with the いつも here.
 
1)
That sentence has two different examples in it, "無意識にする" and "してはいけないと思っていてもそれをしてしまう".

2)_1
Right. You can consider it as a kind of imperative/order, far softer than 書きなさい but stronger than 書いてください.

2)_2
Exactly.

3) a)
It's more likely "stammer". It's the speaker's excuse. She is somehow embarrassed being placated with food. The first い expresses this.

b)
Right.

c)
~とは限らない is a set phrase, meaning "it's not always true that~". In the example sentence, "いつも食べ物で懐柔される" is not always true (so you don't think you'll always be able to~).

EDIT:
You beat me, Glenn-san!🙂
 
Here's another example of とは限らない for you: 光る物の全てが黄金とは限らない (all that glitters is not gold). I can't think of that sentence without hearing it sung in The Real Folk Blues, though.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thank you both.

1)
That sentence has two different examples in it, "無意識にする" and "してはいけないと思っていてもそれをしてしまう"
Duh, of course. For some odd reason I was thinking する/してはいけない was a unit.
 
I will say that the use of that slash threw me off at first, and I find it very strange. I can't recall having seen much of that in Japanese. Probably commas are more common in that type of situation.
 
Back
Top Bottom