You've only addressed one minor aspect of meat. Assuming it's true that it's the highest source of protein that still doesn't address all the other aspects.
From a biblical perspective, the attitude described in the query reflects a partial understanding of Genesis 9:3 but fails to fully consider broader scriptural teachings on the treatment of animals and ethical consumption.
Biblical Permission to Eat Meat
Genesis 9:3 indeed grants humanity permission to eat animals, stating, "Every moving thing that lives shall be food for you. Just as I gave you the green plants, I now give you everything"
16. This permission marked a shift from the original plant-based diet prescribed in Genesis 1:29. However, this allowance came after the Flood, when vegetation was scarce, and was accompanied by restrictions, such as the prohibition against consuming blood (Genesis 9:4) and later distinctions between clean and unclean animals (Leviticus 11)
6.
Ethical Treatment of Animals
While Genesis 9:3 permits meat consumption, it does not endorse cruelty or indifference toward animals. Many Christian theologians emphasize stewardship over creation, which involves treating animals with care and respect. For instance:
- The Catechism of the Catholic Church calls for avoiding unnecessary suffering to animals and emphasizes humane treatment4.
- Karl Barth argued that killing animals for food should only occur under necessity and must be done with reverence3.
Scripture also highlights that God cares for all His creatures (Psalm 145:9), and cruelty toward animals is inconsistent with biblical principles of stewardship and compassion
34.
Balancing Biblical Principles
The attitude expressed—indifference to animal suffering while consuming mistreated meat—contradicts broader biblical themes of stewardship and ethical responsibility. While eating meat is permissible, Christians are called to reflect on their choices in light of compassion and respect for creation. This includes supporting practices that reduce animal suffering and promote humane treatment
45.
In summary, while Genesis 9:3 allows meat consumption, biblical teachings encourage mindful stewardship that avoids unnecessary harm to animals. Indifference to their conditions conflicts with this ethical responsibility.