Learn Kanji Reading Manga..?

cheapshot

後輩

30 Nov 2004

220

1

• 29 Mar 2005

• #1

came across this in my local comic book shop today:

clicky

just wondered if anybody had actually used it

i was just going to by a japanese manga -

this one actually.

would it be extremely difficult to get into reading a manga like this..? i presume it would be which is why i didnt buy it i might try to get a manga that is aimed at small children to help with my knaji recognition. in which case.... does anyone have any suggestions.?

yorkii

 

Stutz

先輩

10 Oct 2004

73

1

• 29 Mar 2005

• #2

Uh....is that the copy of it or does it look more like this:



Because if it looks like the image you posted, you have the American version of FMA which will have no kanji or kana period.

To answer your question, manga will help your reading and might help you recognize a few kanji, but it won't really teach you kanji from my experience. You'll learn more from learning radicals than you'll ever learn from manga. But that's what I've noticed in my studies.

 

D

dc_johnson45

先輩

1 Feb 2005

47

1

• 31 Mar 2005

• #3

I think you might want to stay away from using manga as your source for learning kanji. While it might be a good suppliment to your language studies (mostly to boost your confidence when you can 'read' some manga!), its not going to give you a structured approach to learning and memorizing.

That book looks interesting.. I might have to pick up a copy.

Personally, for kanji, I learn the vocabulary for my Japanese class in kanji. Its 'above and beyond' the scope of the class, but I actually find it helps me remember the words better. I get a little picture for each word!

 

cheapshot

後輩

30 Nov 2004

220

1

• 31 Mar 2005

• Thread starter
• #4

Stutz said:

Uh....is that the copy of it or does it look more like this:



Because if it looks like the image you posted, you have the American version of FMA which will have no kanji or kana period.

To answer your question, manga will help your reading and might help you recognize a few kanji, but it won't really teach you kanji from my experience. You'll learn more from learning radicals than you'll ever learn from manga. But that's what I've noticed in my studies.

Click to expand...

thats the one i was going to get... i couldnt find a pic of it though

i got this in the end: Basic Japanese Through Comics just to supplement my learning. it looks quite good so far

 

Hiroyuki Nagashima

TAN

Twenty-year veteran

18 Jan 2005

11,686

3,654

• 3 Apr 2005

• #5

It seems that the 2nd volume is put on the market.
The cover of the 2nd volume is better than the 1st volume. Did the really same author write?

Manga University Campus Store

 

cheapshot

後輩

30 Nov 2004

220

1

• 4 Apr 2005

• Thread starter
• #6

yes its by the same author

 

S

sketchytiger

*+Mangaka/Illustrator+*

21 Apr 2005

34

0

• 23 Apr 2005

• #7

...i hate the american version...

although to tell you the truth, a lot of mangas have furigana next to the kanji, which is all hiragana pronunciation of the kanjis and what they mean. I have fullmetal alchemist vol.1 and peacemaker kurogane vol.1-4 and 2 shonen jump magazine in japanese. all of them have furigana in 'em and it's very helpful [if you happen to have a dictionary next to you when you start reading XD;;]