Kishida met with reporters in the evening of Nov. 11 and explained that he was appointing Ken Saito, a former agriculture minister, to replace Hanashi. Just before that, Hanashi met with Kishida to hand him his resignation. Hanashi then told reporters he was stepping down. "I used the term 'death sentence' too lightly," Hanashi said. "I caused the public and Justice Ministry officials to hold uncomfortable feelings. I have also caused Diet deliberations to stall." Kishida had just publicly defended Hanashi that morning in an appearance at the Upper House plenary session. He explained to lawmakers that Hanashi would remain in his post since the minister had retracted his remark and apologized for it. But Kishida apparently changed his mind shortly afterward. Even lawmakers from the ruling Liberal Democratic Party were flabbergasted by the remark made by Hanashi on Nov. 9 at a gathering of LDP lawmakers, and some openly speculated it would cost him his job.