Let me tell you, a little while ago, this game called "Assassin's Creed: Shadows: was released. It was set in Japan. One of the main characters was a Black Samurai. He was not accepted well, and consequently, Ubisoft was accused of being woke, and needlessly including DEI in their games. The Japanese did not like the black Samurai. They felt his inclusion undermined the main characters story, since she was native Japanese. They went so far as to call him a "Fake Samurai". Further, the entire premise, two Asian people having a black child is scientifically impossible, since Samurais were around in a time when Japan did not have any contact with outsiders, therefore making it scientifically impossible for the child to be born black. Further, it is very likely that the Japanese will be very offended by that. If you want to make it, go for it. But you have been warned.i want to make a comic called
the last black samurai
its conterversial
where a child from a japanese family is born and his skin is black
so the parents throw the baby in the ocean
and he floats across the ocean and is raised by a black family in america
and goes back to japan to reclaim his name as the samurai of japan
but the japanese people never accept him and keep blaming him for
crimes he didnt commit and has to live as a hermit
working to bring justice to the people of japan
but as you can imagine i dont want to offend people
( I was going to make the comic the black chinese revolutionary and
found out the hard way china does not want a black chinese revolution)
tell me what you think
and remember I love you and only want success and friendship
New photo · Wednesday, Apr 22
seems like random idiots on twitter are driving your impression over what constitutes a "controversy," looks to me like a shadow of gamergate. Some people are just addicted to outrage.Let me tell you, a little while ago, this game called "Assassin's Creed: Shadows: was released. It was set in Japan. One of the main characters was a Black Samurai. He was not accepted well, and consequently, Ubisoft was accused of being woke, and needlessly including DEI in their games. The Japanese did not like the black Samurai. They felt his inclusion undermined the main characters story, since she was native Japanese. They went so far as to call him a "Fake Samurai". Further, the entire premise, two Asian people having a black child is scientifically impossible, since Samurais were around in a time when Japan did not have any contact with outsiders, therefore making it scientifically impossible for the child to be born black. Further, it is very likely that the Japanese will be very offended by that. If you want to make it, go for it. But you have been warned.
Your gaming and I appreciate youseems like random idiots on twitter are driving your impression over what constitutes a "controversy," looks to me like a shadow of gamergate. Some people are just addicted to outrage.
@jane88618 There will always be critics no matter what you do; the comment above mine is talking about a character that is actually based on a historical figure. You are free to make whatever art you want. Your storyline is far-fetched, and you might some day look back and cringe (as we all hopefully do when we look back at our past work), but the world's longest pieces of written works are fan fictions... so like, literally nothing matters... just do what you want and what amuses yourself while you can as long as it doesn't cause unnecessary harm.
Here's some perspective:
Thank youYasuke was a real person. See more info here.
In your situation, it's a purely fictional scenario so you would probably not see as much resistance.
Well, not at least until it's made into a popular movie or video game.
As for as what's scientifically possible or not, that doesn't really matter. That's the beauty of fiction. You can make up the reason if you care to elaborate. Perhaps your protagonist has Jomon (Ainu) heritage who had darker features than the Yayoi, the lighter skinned Asians that came from Korea and dominate now. And the alleles for this recessive gene somehow got activated by the toxic ashfall from a volcano (Mt Fuji, Kumamoto etc), producing unexpectedly deep melanin expression akin to Southeast Asian tones.
I won't try to argue that no one cares, since you seem to.@mdchachi @nice gaijin
Yasuke was a real person, but even then, his inclusion in Shadows was not very well accepted at all. I personally recommend you just don't add a black Samurai. Even the real Yasuke was not treated like a real Samurai by his enemies, and therefore was not allowed to commit seppuku when he was captured.
The Fight Over a Black Samurai in Assassin’s Creed Shadows (Published 2024)
The video game franchise long emphasized its historical accuracy in settings such as Athens, Florence and London. Then details of its first foray to Japan were attacked online.www.nytimes.com
Assassin's Creed Shadow Sparks Controversy Over Black Samurai
Yasuke was a samurai, believed to have been of African origin. But his presence in the game sparked a debate among fans.time.com
I really don't care. He wanted to know how it might be accepted, I gave him an answer. Stop getting the idea that I'm doing something wrong when other people here give help about people wanting to go into Japanese Porn.I won't try to argue that no one cares, since you seem to.
Unfortunately, it's such a common occurrence that we do have a word for people who care about the race of a fictional character...
You gave an answer based the fact that a few people objected to a character in a video game.I really don't care. He wanted to know how it might be accepted, I gave him an answer. Stop getting the idea that I'm doing something wrong when other people here give help about people wanting to go into Japanese Porn.
That's not true. Japan for Black Lives - 人種差別について学び、考える。|まずは差別の現状を知ること。そして共感し、学び、声を上げ、世の中を良くする。Furthermore, racial discrimination against black people does not exist in Japan. Therefore, having dark skin is not particularly considered a problem. The only discrimination that exists in Japan is discrimination against foreigners.
Yes of course. Even in Japan, though, there is a ranking of foreigners based on skin color. Black people get worse discrimination than white. And, even worse, it's not just foreigners, Japanese people of mixed race get profiled and hassled because they look foreign.Konnichiwa mdchachi-san!
You've forgotten that black people are also "foreigners."
NANGI
Where did you get the idea that 'Furthermore, racial discrimination against Black people does not exist in Japan'?Konnichiwa mdchachi-san!
Yes, your opinion is spot on! Japanese people discriminate against not only mixed-race but also person who have returned from overseas, treating them as foreigners. Even if they were pure Japanese...
Ultimately, the targets of Japanese discrimination depend on whether or not they share the same values and behaviors as themselves.
If black people feel they are more likely to be discriminated against than white people in Japan, it may be because Western stereotypes about black people are influencing Japanese people.
The Japanese are good at incorporating other cultures into their own, even if those cultures are bad...
I've strayed from the main topic, but in fiction, there's absolutely no problem with depicting a black samurai. The story would gain more realism if it could depict the suffering of Japanese person who, despite being Japanese, is not accepted in Japan simply because he/she have returned from overseas.
NANGI
Incidentally, I also get stopped by the police quite often, even though I'm neither Black nor a criminal. Could it be that not only foreigners but also Japanese people are being discriminated against?
thomas-san, have you never been stopped and questioned by the police? Are you invisible man? Or are you a nice guy who everyone would consider a gentleman? I thought that all foreigners were discriminated against, but I might need to change my perspective.
Hi Nangi-san,Konnichiwa mdchachi-san!
I said ...
"Furthermore, racial discrimination against black people does not exist in Japan. Therefore, having dark skin is not particularly considered a problem. The only discrimination that exists in Japan is discrimination against foreigners."
What I want to emphasize most is that people are discriminated against not because of the color of their skin, but because they are foreigners(Please understand the entire text without taking any parts out of context.).
In your opinion, it seems that only Black people are discriminated against in Japan, while Asians, white people, Hispanics, Muslims, etc., are not.
I feel that many foreigners are equally discriminated against, regardless of their skin color or religion. Am I wrong? Or is it just Black people who are treated worse than other foreigners in Japan?
I have very few foreign friends in my personal life. The only ones I knew were a white person and a Hispanic person a long time ago. We weren't particularly close, but my Hispanic acquaintance seemed to want my help.
Unfortunately, our relationship wasn't close enough for me to intrude on his private life, so I wasn't able to help him. It's easy to imagine that, as a foreigner, he must have faced many difficulties living in Japan.
He was a second (or third) Japanese Hispanic, but I think that doesn't mean his struggles were easier than those of Black people.
I found an article about police questioning of people with "foreign roots." The article stated that foreigners of all nationalities, regardless of whether they are Black or not, are being questioned by the police.
「外国にルーツ」への職質 過去5年で6割 弁護士会調査
The percentage of people stopped and questioned by police based on their ethnic origins was 84% in Central and South America, 83% in Africa, and 76% in the Middle East.
In all cases, the percentages were high, and it didn't seem like only people of African descent were experiencing discrimination. Personally, I still feel that foreigners are discriminated against regardless of their skin color black or not.
Incidentally, I also get stopped by the police quite often, even though I'm neither Black nor a criminal. Could it be that not only foreigners but also Japanese people are being discriminated against?
NANGI
All very good, thought-provoking questions!Konnichiwa Lothor-san! And Mina-san!
Wow, I made a mistake with the name and made a terrible mistake. I'm so sorry. And thank you for replying(I have corrected the mistake.)
This isn't a response to your previous post, but I'd like to ask for your advice if you don't mind. It might be a really silly question, but please don't laugh and tell me.
Are Black people discriminated against because of the color of their skin? Or is discrimination an extension of the history of friction between Africans (and people of African descent) and white people?
I know that Black people face discrimination in America, and in other country as well. However, I thought that it wasn't because of the color of their skin, but rather an extension of the history of hardship that Black people have endured.
For example, in Japan, there are a few people who think that having dark skin is cool.
When I was a child, tanned skin was considered a sign of good health. Therefore, after summer vacation ended, the friend with the most tanned and darkest skin was the class hero.
Also, when I was young, I had a friend who was a "ガングロギャル:ganguro gal." Her hands and face were completely black, but I thought it suited her very well and looked great.
In recent years, tanning has been said to be a cause of skin cancer, and it has become fashionable to avoid darkening the skin. However, bodybuilders and others still try their best to darken their skin.
For Japanese people, who don't feel any aversion to dark skin, I've always thought that prejudice and discrimination against Black people stem not from their skin color, but from the history of hardship they have endured. Is this incorrect?
Could it be that having dark skin itself is considered a religious taboo or something similar in the West? Is having dark skin inherently a crime? Some Japanese people think that having dark skin is attractive, but is this a minority view globally?
Am I being unreasonable for even separating racial discrimination against Black people from skin color?
I used to think that discrimination was caused by mutual ignorance, and that people could get along regardless of skin color through mutual understanding, but am I wrong?
My argument might sound completely meaningless. But I hope someone will show me a new path while I'm confused.
NANGI
Even I have been visa checked albeit after midnight doing a conbini run, impressive you never have.@NANGI -san, just out of curiosity, are you being stopped as a pedestrian, a cyclist, or a motorist? What reasons do they give for stopping you? I've been cycling in Japan for over 20 years and have never been stopped or questioned by the police [knock on wood].
Even I have been visa checked albeit after midnight doing a conbini run, impressive you never have.