Rosetta Stone course

Joined
26 Mar 2005
Messages
240
Reaction score
0
Does anyone know if the Rosetta Stone course is any good? It might not really be worth asking since I'm getting it tomorrow anyway ^^; , but if anyone could give me info it would help... I'm getting levels 1 and 2

I'll write a review or something on it when I'm done.
 
Hi phantasmagoria -

We have the Rosetta Stone Level 1 program. While I haven't finished it yet, I can tell you what I think so far. Its teaching method is interesting, but I'm not sure I would be able to learn Japanese well using Rosetta Stone alone. It probably depends on your personal learning style, though.

Rosetta Stone doesn't teach any grammar at all (at least in the first few levels). I think the reasoning behind this is that you'll learn the same way children do -- by osmosis. In reality, I'm not sure how well it can work. Personally, not knowing how the language is put together makes me unhappy. ;)

So, while I do use Rosetta Stone, I'm also doing the Pimsleur audio course and studying grammar in books & online. I've also learned the kana and have begun working on kanji. I recommend that you at least try to learn hiragana while you're doing Rosetta Stone. This will help you in innumerable ways.

P.S. I have found one error in Rosetta Stone's romanization. They romanized 何本か (なんぼんか) as "nambonka." There's no "~amb~" sound possible in Japanese, as far as I know...:P Yet another great reason to learn Hiragana! Also they've used some constructs which I'm not sure are the most common or natural ways to express the thoughts they represent. Though, since I'm a novice, you definitely shouldn't trust me for this kind of information. ;)
 
Rosetta stone is OK for supplementing other material, but definitely you shouldn't use it by itself like wakarimasen said, since it doesn't explain much. Personally I'm not a big fan of RS, I tried it and it just didn't do anything for me... just my 2 cents tho
 
8 year bump - Just got the latest Rosetta Stone course! Still downloading though, so I haven't had a chance to begin.
 
I tried Rosetta stone first before anything else, got to memorize some vocabularies and that's about it. as for grammar, got to read books rather than learning in rosetta stone.
 
So I've used it a bit so far, and I like it. It's the newest version, level 1. I'm using it together with Yes Japan!'s "Japanese From Zero!" Level 1. Its nice to have both interactive and text-book learning. Kinda simulates school in a strange way.
 
Rosetta Stone is pretty good

Does anyone know if the Rosetta Stone course is any good? It might not really be worth asking since I'm getting it tomorrow anyway ^^; , but if anyone could give me info it would help... I'm getting levels 1 and 2
I'll write a review or something on it when I'm done.

I've heard a lot of opinions about Rosetta Stone over the years, so I figured I'd throw mine into the mix.

I used RS about 10 years ago when I was starting out, and it didn't work very well at first. I was trying to use it more or less as designed, by associating phrases with pictures. That proved to be confusing, because it wasn't always clear what the images were depicting, and I couldn't always distinguish the words clearly (this is especially a problem if you're just starting out).

But once I reached a bit of an intermediate level, I actually got a lot of value out of RS, and now I think it's pretty good. Here's what I did differently:

1. I listened to each phrase and looked at the picture, but this time while reading the kanji. Anything I couldn't read, I flipped over to the hiragana and read that.

2. Then--and here's the critical part--I looked up any words I didn't know in a dictionary. Trying to figure everything out from context often resulted in misunderstanding. But once you look things up, and clearly understand the sentence, it's much easier to remember.

3. After that, I'd simply review the phrases and repeat them a few times throughout the day. I didn't bother with the speech recognition software.

If you use RS like that, you will learn a lot of basic vocabulary and sentence constructions, and in that I think it's pretty effective. It'll also familiarize you with many of the common kanji.

Rosetta Stone won't make you fluent, but it will increase your ability, which is maybe all you could hope for from a software package.
 
IMHO, I think you need to use the Rosetta Stone (or Pimsleur) as a supplement to a good grammar book. I tried this before (for Korean) but I eventually had to give up because I cannot connect it to actual scenarios, for some reason. I felt I was just parroting along and I really didn't grasp what the sentences meant.
But if you can get a good grammar material (online or a book), you will find better results with Rosetta Stone. Some good grammar books would be:
Genki
Japanese for Busy People
Minna no Nihongo
A Dictionary of Basic/Intermediate/Advanced Japanese Grammar
 
Back
Top Bottom