This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

News Japan-South Korean relations

Here are a few updates on the thaw in the relations between South Korea and Japan:


The first of three surviving South Korean plaintiffs in a wartime labour lawsuit against Japanese companies has accepted compensation from a South Korean government-affiliated foundation.




Paywall alert:





On Sunday, the defence ministers of Japan and South Korea agreed to accelerate talks on ways to prevent radar lock-on incidents between their forces, with an alleged case in 2018 that had undermined confidence between the countries' defence authorities.






Reuters reports that young South Koreans drive a shift in attitudes towards Japan that involves anime, beer, whisky, and more.


 
On Tuesday, South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol called Japan a "partner" that shares his country's values and common interests as he aims to strengthen ties with Tokyo in response to North Korea's growing nuclear threats.


Watch AFP's Youtube video here (they do not allow embedding).


 
Normalisation is going slow: after more than a decade, a majority of the Japanese people view South Korea positively.



The proportion of Japanese with a negative view of South Korea has been larger since 2013. However, the survey also shows that only 28.9 per cent of 1,008 South Koreans surveyed have a positive view of Japan, a slight decrease from the previous year. 53.5 per cent have a negative attitude towards Japan.


 
A grand humanitarian gesture. South Korea's air force seems better equipped to respond quickly to such emergencies.


 
Nikkei Asia examined why South Korea's general elections on 10 April did not provoke the usual Japan-bashing.



Voters, however, did not respond to those attacks, and Japan did not become an election issue. Public protests over the release of the treated Fukushima wastewater have been small.

Why?
  • Japan's historical approach to making concessions to South Korea has shifted. Recent Japanese Prime Ministers, including Shinzo Abe and his successors, have adopted a more steadfast stance, refusing to yield to Seoul's demands, regardless of their intensity.
  • South Korea's confidence as an advanced economy has grown, and it now hosts numerous multinational corporations. Consequently, Japan is perceived as just one of many countries. Despite lingering anti-Japanese sentiment due to historical colonial rule, recent elections have not prominently focused on these tensions, reflecting a societal shift where Japan's influence at the ballot box has diminished.
  • Foreign policy is a critical factor in South Korean opinion polls supporting Yoon. As one of the current administration's positive aspects, it is expected to remain a priority for Yoon until his term concludes in 2027. Improving relations with Japan may play a role in this endeavour.
  • Younger, social media-savvy voters exhibit less party loyalty and vote based on specific issues or candidates. They tend to have a global and pragmatic outlook, emphasizing human rights and gender issues. The growing negative sentiment toward China reflects their opposition to authoritarianism. These trends may offer insights into Japan's relations with South Korea.
  • According to a South Korean government source, Japan and South Korea align their votes on United Nations resolutions approximately 98% of the time. Despite their bilateral issues, both nations share common values related to democracy, free markets, and strategic interests in the global economy.

Paywall alert:
 
I was reading somewhere, I guess it was Twitter, where some cynical commenters where saying any warming of relations was surely only temporary, because Korea would revert to an anti-Japan posture as elections ramped up. I'm very glad to see those commenters were wrong, and that it definitely looks like a there is a generation of Koreans who aren't interested in carrying the historical baggage that their parents and grandparents carried.
 
More sign of normalisation: South Korean tourists are flocking to Japan in record numbers, driven by a weak Japanese currency and improved bilateral ties, making the country an attractive destination once again. According to the Japan National Tourism Organization, 3.73 million South Korean tourists visited Japan in the first five months, a 1.4-fold increase from the previous year. In May alone, 730,000 South Koreans arrived, setting a monthly record. Despite past diplomatic tensions and a significant drop in South Korean tourists due to the 2019 "No Japan" movement, Japan remains a top destination for South Korean travellers.




Paywall alert:
 
The Economist examined the Japanese-South Korean relationship and found that younger generations are less concerned with their country's shared history.





 
According to Nikkei Asia, South Korea welcomed the 'anti-Abe' Ishiba, who had gained popularity for opposing the late PM Shinzo Abe.

South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol and his administration likely felt relieved by Shigeru Ishiba's election as leader of Japan's ruling Liberal Democratic Party and the country's new prime minister on September 27. While both the U.S. and China have concerns about Ishiba's security policies, he is seen positively in South Korea for standing up to former PM Abe, whom many South Koreans view as a far-right historical revisionist.

South Korean media, both conservative and liberal, have praised Ishiba. Conservative daily Chosun Ilbo highlighted his candid advice to Abe, while liberal paper Hankyoreh noted Ishiba's criticism of Abe, who once held significant power. Abe's legacy casts a shadow over South Korean-Japanese relations, with his political influence rooted in his controversial grandfather. Unlike Abe, Ishiba is viewed as a more cautious "dove," mainly due to his reluctance to visit the Yasukuni Shrine, which honours Japan's war dead, including war criminals.



Paywall alert:
 
Japan through Korean eyes: Stars & Stripes published a heartwarming piece by Hyemin Lee, a reporter of Korean ancestry, on her first assignment to Japan.



While Ms Lee initially held negative views about Japan, these perceptions were drastically altered after her visit. Tokyo's sophistication, cleanliness, safety, organization, and friendliness greatly impressed the author, contrasting starkly with their experiences in other regions. The author also noted the striking similarities between Japan and Korea, particularly regarding urban landscapes, tourist demographics, and cultural influences.

And:


Read the whole story here:

 
South Korean President Yoon Suk-yeol's sudden declaration of martial law on Tuesday has disrupted the positive momentum in Japan-South Korea relations, which had been fostered with U.S. support. While the state of emergency was lifted shortly after, the incident has forced Japanese officials to reassess their engagement with South Korea. PM Ishiba expressed the need to closely monitor the situation and make informed decisions, raising concerns about the future of the planned summit between the two leaders in January.





Paywall alert:

The NYT sees even broader implications:

 
According to a recent Kyodo poll, over 70% of the Japanese worry that South Korea's turmoil will affect ties with Japan.

This is probably a legitimate concern. Japan has always fared better with conservative South Korean governments.


 
PM Ishiba and newly elected South Korean President Lee Jae-myung had their first phone call yesterday, during which they agreed on the need to enhance bilateral relations between their respective countries.




In the past, Lee has sharply criticised the previous conservative administration of Yoon Suk-yeol over its "conciliatory" approach toward Japan. In 2023, Lee went on a fast to oppose Japan's release of treated radioactive water from the crippled Fukushima No. 1 nuclear power plant into the ocean. Japanese government officials have expressed both optimism and caution over the future of bilateral relations under South Korea's first progressive president in about three years.

 
A recent survey has shown that public sentiment and perceptions regarding current Japan–South Korea relations have become more favourable in both countries compared to findings from a similar poll conducted ten years earlier. The joint opinion survey, conducted by The Asahi Shimbun and South Korea's Dong-A Ilbo, was carried out in commemoration of the 60th anniversary of the normalisation of diplomatic relations.


Provided by Asahi


In Japan, the percentage of respondents who expressed a liking for South Korea increased from 10% in 2015 to 19% in the latest poll. Likewise, those who felt that the relationship between the two countries was "going well" increased from 7% to 29%. Despite these improvements, expectations for the future of bilateral relations remained largely the same as they were a decade ago, with only 17% of Japanese respondents believing that ties will progress in a more "positive direction."

 
More news on the political and economic relationship between Japan and South Korea:

Despite his fiercely critical stance during his first tenure, newly elected South Korean President Lee Jae Myung has surprised policymakers and analysts with his unexpectedly conciliatory stance toward Japan. The underlying theme of Lee's approach so far has been clear: "Japan first" -- signalling a prioritisation of Japan over the U.S. This choice is driven not merely by the difficulty of arranging a summit with Trump, but by a deliberate recalibration of Seoul's foreign policy priorities.


President Lee is set to travel to Japan on the 23rd and 24th of August, ahead of a summit with Trump in Washington on the 25th.

Paywall alert:


Meanwhile, several Japanese retailers (Don Quijote, Muji) opened new outlets in South Korea. However, many Japanese companies fear the country's lingering anti-Japan sentiment, which has been declining, but to which generations over 40 are already accustomed. If another Japanese product boycott occurred, they would subconsciously agree with it or stand back and watch.

Paywall alert:
 
South Korean President Lee Jae Myung indicated that he would adhere to the existing agreements with Japan connected to its colonial rule of the Korean peninsula, including the one concerning Korean women who had been forced to work in military brothels. Lee acknowledged that the legacy of Japanese colonisation from 1910 to 1945 remained a politically sensitive matter for both nations, with many of the surviving so-called "comfort women" still demanding a formal apology and compensation from Tokyo.

Although Lee's own Democratic Party had opposed the deal, he was quoted in an interview with Japan's Yomiuri Shimbun, published shortly before his planned summit in Tokyo with Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba, as saying that the agreement was a difficult one for South Koreans to accept. Nevertheless, he maintained that since it had been entered into as a national commitment, it would be undesirable for his administration to overturn it.

The pact, reached in 2015 under South Korea's then-conservative government, had included an apology from Japan and the provision of 1 billion yen (about $6.8 million) for a fund to support the victims. At the time, both governments had agreed that the issue would be "irreversibly resolved" if each side carried out its responsibilities. Despite such arrangements, disputes over wartime forced labour and the treatment of comfort women have continued to cast a shadow over relations between Japan and its neighbours, especially South Korea and China.

 
I lived and worked in korea three different times--19 months in the army spanning parts of '71 to '73, two years in the peace corps kind of calendar '74 and '75, and then a year teaching in calendar '84.

Anti-japan-ism (and the 'comfort women' issue) hadn't really taken off or been developed, even by the final time I lived there. Koreans who lived near US bases and could get AFKN radio and TV (low power, so very local) felt lucky. And those around Pusan were luckier still, since they could get broadcasts from japan--in all these cases meaning uncensored.

The first two times Pak Chung-Hee was 'president', and it showed. Things were pretty repressive. I was in health (TB control) but there were uni-level TESOL teachers in peace corps who, even tho they went thru the motions of setting up and living/teaching there, literally never taught a class over their two years stints as PCVs, since the universities were closed to prevent protests (they just traveled around korea and visited other volunteers--such luck!). Kathy Stephens got there as a PCV about a year after I did, and later became US ambassador. (Gee, I guess fate passed me over?)

My next stay there in '84, Chun Doo-Hwan was firmly in power, and the Kwangju/Gwangju 'uprising' was already history, and most eyes looked towards the '88 olympics (korea being envious of japan's '64 hosting, and the '88 hosting being seen as the metric for having "made it" into equality or being on par with japan and other developed/hosting nations.

And the history of this dates back to the 1965 "agreement"--and huge payment by japan to korea, which was conveniently redirected to 'national development' instead of being used as reparations.


The compensation then, direct aid and loans over ten years, was US$500 million. And if I am googling correctly, that amount is the equivalent of over $5 billion in today's dollars. A major part of it went to Pohang Iron and Steel--and while koreans think they did it themselves, Pohang would never have happened without this money. Maybe Pohang Iron and Steel should spend a little thank-you money on the comfort women whose misplaced compensation created it?

The comfort women issue, which didn't gain its own life until the '90s, is similar to trump's demonization of immigrants--pure politics. And koreans don't then also demonize americans, to whom they pandered in almost the same way for a couple of decades after the japanese were gone. Korea when under japanese 'rule' was the same as the vichy government during WWII in france--huge amounts of collaboration with the occupiers, and then denial of that after the fact.

blah, blah, blah...
 
Reminds me a bit of Japan's ODA to China:


Anyhow, I am very pleased to see that Pres. Lee is serious about reconciliation with Japan:






 
These two really hit it off.


South Korean president Lee Jae Myung and Japan's prime minister Sanae Takaichi join a joint drum performance, playing to Golden from K-Pop Demon Hunters and BTS's Dynamite.


Good to see South Korea and Japan in tune with each other!


 
Yes, I have to agree. It's all about the gesture.

I was in a talent show in high school. We were an air band and pretended to play against a real track (by Jane's Addiction). An actual high school band had their drum set on the stage and they let me sit at their kit and pretend to play.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…