This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

Is my sentence right?

Tomii515

やった~!
Joined
16 Feb 2006
Messages
1,206
Reaction score
21
Why are you cleaning?

Naze anata wa soji o shimas ka?

naze=why
anata wa=you
soji o shimas=clean (verb)
ka=makes it a question

is this right?
 
Tomii515 said:
Why are you cleaning?
Naze anata wa soji o shimas ka?
naze=why
anata wa=you
soji o shimas=clean (verb)
ka=makes it a question
is this right?
This is not quite correct, Tomii515, sorry !

To talk about things happening right now you will change the verb to the progressive tense and make it like the one below. Have you studied verb endings and tenses yet at all ? If not, maybe you should look at a text or something first since it's kinda confusing to explain....but let me know if you have questions after that !

Naze, anata wa souji wo shiteimasuka ?
 
I don't think you would need to say 'anata wa' in this sentance either, it would be clear who was doing the cleaning already.

naze soujiwo shiteimasuka?
 
Well I think if he is coming from a beginner perspective. shimasu would be correct. We normally don't learn te forms til 102. so...maybe for now it is correct but he will learn more forms later maybe.
 
前後もあるし たぶん何がいいたかたのがわかりますが、「掃除をする」は、「将来は、なぜ。。。とか大抵、なぜ。。。」と意味がはっきりしていますね。

Is this sentence right のか聞いているのかなと思います。
 
Tomii515 said:
Why are you cleaning?
Naze anata wa soji o shimas ka?
soji o shimas=clean (verb)
So I just looked at this again.
To me 'souji wo shiteimasu' sounds more like 'doing the cleaning', compared to 'souji shiteimasu', just 'cleaning'. I only really mentioned because you listed 'souji wo shimasu' there as just one verb, which if you wanted you should use 'souji shimasu'.

I just looked at google and there were a few hundred hits using this form:
何かを掃除をしている。
Is this actually an acceptable sentence? 何かを掃除している would sound better probably?
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…