This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

Help with Good luck flags

Jack98

Kouhai
Joined
21 Jul 2024
Messages
57
Reaction score
23
Hi everyone, I'm new here. I love to collect military items. Now, would like to purchase a japanese Yosegaki Hinomaru flag. I found these two flags that seems interesting to me, but I would like to have your opinion about them. What do you think?
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20240925_150638.webp
    158.8 KB · Views: 165
  • IMG_20240925_150616.webp
    143.6 KB · Views: 156
Sorry, I posted this also in another forum to have a major number of opinion . Of course, i would like to have your opinion too. Thanks to everyone.
 
I can't comment to the authenticity of the flags, but the one on the right, with most of the text radiating out from the central sun is really interesting to me. If authentic, it comes from the Nagoya branch of Nakano Vinegar, the precursor to Mizkan.

Sorry, this is all in Japanese. They don't have the detailed history in English.

Edit: Updated the spelling of Mizkan.
 
I think they are both interesting, and have a high probability of being authentic. Both have names of recipients, and the giver (or representative) is identifiable, meaning there is a specific person or organization that presented the flags. So, these are the kinds of things that add plausibility to a flag, as opposed to a flag that is just covered in random names.
 
Thanks you. And in your opinion which Is the most interesting?
 
Thank you
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think maybe the one on the right (same as Mikawa Ossan), for the same reason he mentioned. It's a known company/brand, and one could validate the name (or names) on it presumably by contacting the company and see if they are willing to search through their archives for the names on it. Other possible methods of validating exist. The important thing is that there is a verifiable company name on it, and the name of a person who is presumably associated with that company, so it has some plausible and verifiable connection with reality.

The one on the left... after looking at it a bit more I'm not as convinced as I was when I looked at it earlier. It too has some names on it that could be validated, but I don't like the looks of some of the abbreviations.

Note: I am not a native speaker of Japanese, and so my grasp of the language is less firm than a native speaker's grasp.
 
Ok, thank you again. One last question, if i'm not wrong in the part in which Is written the giver, the first part of the phrase Is "Nakano shop". So this Nakano shop is the the precursor of Mizkan, and not a differenti society, right?
 
Yes, I would say the one on the right is more interesting - but its all subjective. I like it because of the verifiable company name, the slogan at the top (必勝 - certain victory), and I like how the names radiate out from the red disc.
 
Yes, I would say the one on the right is more interesting - but its all subjective. I like it because of the verifiable company name, the slogan at the top (必勝 - certain victory), and I like how the names radiate out from the red disc.
Thank you. One last question, if i'm not wrong in the part in which Is written the giver, the first part of the phrase Is "Nakano shop". So this Nakano shop is the the precursor of Mizkan, and not a differenti society, right?
 
Hi, I did some research on Mizkan, but I'm not sure if Nakano Vinegar is a company belonging to the Mizkan group, or if it's simply the old name of this company. Do you know anything about it?
 
Yes, it is the old (original) name of the Mizkan group. The founder's surname was Nakano, using a particular kanji. The name on your flag uses this same old, peculiar kanji, so, while not 100% certain, it does indeed look like the name of the company on your flag is the old name for the Mizkan group.

As far as I know the name "Nakano Vinegar" is not in use anymore. Everything has been rolled up into the "Mizkan" corporate brand name.
 
Perfect, thank you as always.
 
If I can ask, which is the particular kanji in the surname?
 

Nakano is normally written as 中野, but this family uses a variant and writes it as 中埜. (Same meaning and pronunciation, just a different kanji variant for no.
 

Nakano is normally written as 中野, but this family uses a variant and writes it as 中埜. (Same meaning and pronunciation, just a different kanji variant for no.
Ok, thank you very much. Is the other slogan (the one written above the donor) the usual "Good luck in battle?". And how does the soldier's name translate?:You know, I would try to do some more research, maybe try to contact the company.
 

The 5 characters arranged vertically on the right are 祈武運長久 (Pray for everlasting luck in battle)
The 5 characters arranged vertically on the left are the recipient's name 清水修平君 (SHIMIZU Shuhei-kun)
"kun" is an honorific used for someone you are familiar with. A work colleague, or friend, or younger family member.
 
Thanks again
 
However (for the right flag), from some research done it would seem that the Nakano Vinegar (Nakano Sumise) it still exists, but now it should only play the role of asset management within the Mizkan group.
 
Hello everyone, sorry again for the disturb. I was wondering if regarding the flag on the left you could help me with the translation of what is written. I see the usual phrase "Good luck in battle" , but otherwise I don't understand much. Additionally, I was wondering if the two locations mentioned are in the same area or completely independent of each other. Thanks in advance everyone.
 
Most of these are names, and its often difficult to know how to pronounce the names even if you can read the characters, because each character has multiple possible readings.

Next to the good luck phrase is 為田和義雄君 (For TAWA Yoshio) which is the name of the recipient. And then maybe one of the presenters under that 安部駒雄 ABE Komao, who may be the head of some local community group. The line next to his name contains the name of this group, based in Tennōji-machi, but I can't parse a couple of the characters: 天王寺町朕全会長. Then you have more names. Then the head of some local defense group KURABE Sei'ichi. Then more names. Then on the far left you have the head of the neighborhood organization for Kita-Kawahori Minami, 山薫 UCHIYAMA Kaoru? (not sure about the bits in red).
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…