This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

God-Emperor

Status
Not open for further replies.
Postwar Japan
http://pc-kirakukan.jp/sankei_kiji20071106.html
boy carrying his dead brother to a crematorium.
Joseph R. O'Donnell September 1945
Joseph O'Donnell; captured images of Hiroshima, 5 presidencies - The Boston Globe
 
May I suggest to write or translate into english, please? This is not the japanese only thread to my knowledge.
 



Now I also don't really think Iraq was a great idea. But your reasoning is simplistic. Iraq was a state that was created, formally the Ottoman Empire. The Ottoman Empire was divided up after World War 1. They didn't pay attention to the the different ethnicities and religious factions so all these different people were made to live under the banner of one country called Iraq. So it would not have been possible for them to have an Emperor. Actually they had the least sectarian violence under Saddam because he was a dictator. He managed to create a secular society, and tried to unite then under the idea of arab unity.

Whether one is against or supports the Iraq war, it is important to understand the history of the middle east. After the Vietnam War, the Middle East was not even on the Americas radar. They had no plan to deal with instability in the MIddle East, they didn't even know if they needed to. Everything was geared towards the Soviet Union. Think tanks within the government started to examine what risks there were. One was if a hostile power where to invade and take over the oil. They then reasoned what if a country within the region were to invade its neighbors and take over the oil creating tremendous instability in the world. Way before(we are talking late 70s, early 80s) Saddam invaded Kuwait they had already reasoned that Iraq invading Kuwait was very possible and highly probable. Since there defeat in Vietnam they decided it would be best to have a regional power police the region. Iran was determined to be the best qualified. They sold arms to the Shah, though they underestimated his stability. He was a dictator, yes, but one that they felt they could influence to take democratic reforms. Ironically pushing too fast too hard he was over come by revolution. He was out of touch. The groups that came together for the revolution could not come up with a way to govern so Islamic hardliners took over in the vacuum.

With that failure in relying on regional powers to take care of things brought forth the notion that America would have to do that.

Of course other countries Japan for example have been able to get oil strictly through negotiation, there have been times where even that would not have been possible without the US military presence in the region.

In hindsight the Iraq war looks like a inevitable result of over decades of securing the middle east. They messed it up pretty bad, the mistakes are documented. Democracy takes decades even centuries to mature, yet they are demanding Iraq be one now. They should have planned for a long occupation.

Long term national interests(securing energy) seem to be what middle east policy is about. Which in itself is not a bad idea. It is good for the world in the long term also. The manner in which they have gone about it though is flawed.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
THREATS AND RESPONSES: THE WHITE HOUSE; U.S. IS COMPLETING PLAN TO PROMOTE A DEMOCRATIC IRAQ (Published 2003)

President Commemorates 60th Anniversary of V-J Day
Briefing Room | The White House

The American President said,
I "assume Japanese occupation time a model" in an Iraqi occupation policy
Thus did it succeed?
 
お願いします・・・皆様 (onegaishimasu ・・・ minasama ~ please. . . everyone)

As in accordance with the theme of the OP, I suggest that we keep the thread on topic, as being concerned with the emperor of Japan's--past or present or future--being divine, of divine nature, or of supernatural descent in any way.

Please do not wander from that. Embedding to support an argument or position is of course ok, but simply bringing up other matters is not. If Japanese is used, please do provide an English rendering, or ask someone who may be able and willing to help do so, to help out in that case.

やっぱ、日本語を使ったら英語の翻訳をも書いた方がいいですね。 (As we can understand, if we use Japanese, it would be nice to write an English translation as well)

Thanks folks !! MM
 

ツ申窶堋オ窶禿ウ窶堋?窶堙ィ窶堙懌?堋ケ窶堙アツ。
Though I looked for English translation of a commentary, it was not found.
Because there was not the confidence that I could translate into English, I copied it in Japanese.
 
A very good article indeed.....

and so true, which ultimately saw Japan suffer more than it should have, at least in the eyes of the "Aliens".

You will notice today that Japanese have a very strong and determined will of mind, they HAVE to get their point accross, and if they believe they are "correct", they will not give up and that's that! Stuff everybody else mentality.

It's gates opened not so long ago, although their still apppears to be some stoppage of sorts..

Things are changing, albeit slowly, as the country modernizers and struggles to internationalize with regular debate..

It does resemble a see-saw, up and down, back and fourth with Alien cards, etc.

Let's hope for the sake of it's children that it straightens itself out soon.
 


Thats basically a psychological reason, as I had explained on several points before. But it does not make a fanatical point more right, in fact, it makes lots of enemies. I have hardly ever seen so many dictators on one place like here. . .unthinkable on other forums, that I attend.

Yes, I do hope, that the internationalisations change the picture again, from within, preferably. I am all for this!
 

It does make enemies and that's the problem.

Japan appears to be struggling to be part of the international democratic community.

Their are many laws and agreements out their with our countries, and Japan is well known for not complying or being a part, although it likes to be known as a friend.

It is also well known for not thinking about what other countries think, but rather hell bent avoiding and ultimately ignoring..
 

Please say clearly.
As for your claim, Japanese Emperor has war responsibility, and is it still to be strange that a position of Japanese Emperor is kept?
I wonder why you made this thread as a political topic not a culture & tradition.


Of course you may discuss anything freely here. Anyone can do.
Go ahead.

Just I leave here.
 
Please say clearly.
As for your claim, Japanese Emperor has war responsibility, and is it still to be strange that a position of Japanese Emperor is kept?

The soldiers were ordered to fight until death for the emperor, were they not?

The Emperor is still in power of sorts, and his position is still engaged?
 
Again, a typical islander mentality on one side. . .but sad enough also downright egocentric. when I realised first, that some japanese former friends in Germany started to take without even thanking, and when I got this confirmed by several others too, I was wondering, whats going on suddenly, but closed my doors for some. (not all, of course, real friends are real friends).
I drastically reduced my helps to zero, although they kept on calling and waving. A certain arrogance and onesidednes is out of my door immediately. No matter from whom or which colour.
This has to be considered to also become a reason for others to close the doors.
It has in fact quite some roots into the "being superior" thinkings, and that is dangerous in general, be it Islam, or Jews or whatnot and in most cases leads to war. Often declared as defence (with mostly hilarious reasons) first to justify it. Very important first signs very often, "racist card". . .particularly projected onto others.

It also shows on smaller, gender level, by the way. Then it is usually time for a divorce.

The soldiers were ordered to fight until death for the emperor, were they not?
The Emperor is still in power of sorts, and his position is still engaged?
Sure, it can happen again, any time.
 
Last edited:
Sure, it can happen again, any time.
That's just nonsense. I think less of 500 people would fight for the emperor right now. So what do you mean with it can happen again, any time.
 
Last edited:
That's just bs. I think less of 500 people would fight for the emperor right now. So what do you mean with it can happen again, any time.

I agree with your comments, DB.

Focusing on the extreme right wing people around Yasukuni and talking about it as if it were the whole Japanese population would surely lead one to say such a thing like "it can happen again, any time".
To me it is something similar to see those into Neo Nazism in Germany and say "it can happen again, any time".
 
The soldiers were ordered to fight until death for the emperor, were they not?

The Emperor is still in power of sorts, and his position is still engaged?

The Emperor has no power. Engaged in nothing that could influence policy.
 
What does the current Emperor think of himself? The only thing I ever hear while in Japan is about the "poor Princess" who didn't have a male child. No one even mentions the Emperor.
 
What does the current Emperor think of himself? The only thing I ever hear while in Japan is about the "poor Princess" who didn't have a male child. No one even mentions the Emperor.

I don't think we will find out what the Emperor thinks of himself. The Imperial household keeps everybody under wraps. Anyway he doesn't really matter much. Emperor Showa is the one who gets debated about in history.
 
...
To me it is something similar to see those into Neo Nazism in Germany and say "it can happen again, any time".

Have you ever heard of any hate crimes here during the lost 20 years?
Nothing similar at all... I think Chi65 would kindly enlighten us on what they are really like.

*snip
In my opinin, "stop and question" by the police in Germany is a bit scarier for me than the shokumu shitsumon in Japan. This is partly because they did not ride 50cc mini-bikes there.
 
That's just bs. I think less of 500 people would fight for the emperor right now. So what do you mean with it can happen again, any time.

I believe Chi was very clear..

It's often said it "can happen again"

Anything is possible and it seems to be a constant battle of fighters..

Goldie girl is right..

When I was their, nothing was spoken of the man himself, but all focus was on the bullying of his daughter-in-law and all the stress she faced..

I can only imagine what went on behind closed doors!
 
Last edited:
Have you ever heard of any hate crimes here during the lost 20 years?

The only thing so far that comes to my mind is that when there're some problems related to Korea (North or South), some Korean school girls in Japan (who can be identified because they were wearing their traditional costume as their uniform) were attached by some Japanese idiots.

But what I wanted to say in my previous post is not that Japanese right winger and Neo Nazism people are the same, I wanted to say that to take a minority as if they were typical and the whole population were like them is not fair and not a good way to get a proper conclusion.
 
How comes, that the pro whalers, who are thought to be the majority (not just 500, right?) are using the same right winger terms then?. . .like our neo Nazis, exactly so, including the denial of the holocaust even, only "japanese way".
Its thus no BS at all and wellknown.
 
Last edited:

I believe this thread is to discuss about if many of the Japanese regard Emperor = god, not about whaling, Right?
You're dragging the whale issue into where you are expected to discuss about the Japanese Emperor (and right-wingers) and you started talking about this issue where people are talking about whaling.
Can you please stay on the topic and not to mix up the issues you have?

When we have discussion on something, the most important thing is to talk based on the facts and truth, not wild assumption or generalization.
 

I suggest, that you read the whole article from the link of the first post. . .

That also includes some "byproducts" of that emperor-cult and leads very well to the above too.
And since the right wingers and the emperor model very well have a relation and as such there was an according question. . .for which the pro-whalers are very well included. . .(I would like to leave them out, but that would be wrong, after all we have seen and heard lately)

No need to play the schoolmaster here, please. I am old and experienced enough, to know exactly what I do. There is no generalisation at all.
I gave some simple and provable facts, if you please recognise them.
But it is not necessary to go any deeper ino this, OK.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…