This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

Clash of Civilizations: What Japan should act?

Astroboy

先輩
Joined
5 Dec 2007
Messages
1,307
Reaction score
26
After Cold War ended, the world has become more diverse....

1. Global Capitalism led by Anglo-American fallen.
2. Fake/Fabrication culture spread by China & Korea facing their limits.
3. Religious conflicts between Islam and Christianity becoming more serious over Middle East and Afghanistan.
4. EU has become more united for being one country - not multi-nations.
6. Russia revives ...


... more and more.

However, Japan remains unchanged - being relatively peacefully - because it
is less affected by external world.

Political scientist Samuel P. Huntington, said JAPAN is uniquely developed civilization with its long history of consistency.


Clash of Civilizations - Wikipedia

Should Japan keep distance from the rest of thw world? or should open more?
 
Capitalism I don't see as "fallen". Despite all the the perceived flaws, American style capitalism remains the most fundamentally sound. There will be down times but because the fundamentals are so strong it should persevere.
I don't quite know what to make of your fake/fabrication culture comment. Sure China has problems respecting tradmarks and intellectual property, but that should get better if they want to be taken seriously and develop into a legitimate economic power. Korea is fine. They have excellent brands. Japan could sometimes learn a thing or two from them.
I'll pass on the Islam/Christianity debate.
Japan has kept their distance long enough and it really isn't doing them much good anymore. I think Japan should do these things:
More spending on education. Data from 2005 shows they lag behind some other countries on percentage of GDP used to fund education. Considering they are the second largest economy in the world and don't really have to spend alot of national defense, why don't they spend more? They should have more top universities, only Todai breaks the top 100 Universities in the world. The second largest economy in the world with only one top 100 University? Fund the creation of more top universities. Or fund programs for American universities to have degree programs in Japan. They should streamline the process, a common application for all Universities and one test(with no English) for all universities. That would mean those without much money could still apply for all universities. Rehaul the whole curriculum. Why is it that kids go to school then have to go to juku for hours? What the hell are they teaching in school? My sister goes to Keio Highschool and she has a teacher who gives points back to students on test grades if they write the answer ten times for homework, you can't fail a test! There should scholarships, grants and low interest student loans for students without the means to pay for a top education. Eliminate the exam hell. Make interviews and grades and essays count. Make them work in college, no easy rides for 4 years.
The government should pressure businesses to be more productive and create a culture where you don't have to go drinking after work and fathers can go home at 5 or 6 instead of 11 or 12. Corporate tax breaks, whatever some incentive. I think pension payments should be optional. I don't want to pay those premiums and see a bunch of idiots handling that money, I can do a better job with my money.
Relax immigration. Let them in! In the long run it will benefit Japan economically.
Change election laws. The election laws now just reinforce the one party system they have.
More lawyers. We need them here.
 
Capitalism: I DO hope so, but since communisim fallen in late 1980s, Anglo-American capitalism seems to go to extreme greed, and likely to show no sign of touching bottom. Smaller share of extreme rich cannot continue to dominate majority of poor in the USA or others. Simply unsustainable.
I think that Anglo-American capitalism returned to the era before Marx and Lenin. I believe that New Communisim will emerge soon or later.

Fake/fabrication: I'll pass on the debate. But I do like China-Free products now to save my life, and also fed up with Korean pirate copies.

More spending on education: Agree.

More productive: Partly agree, but Japan should seek "more outputs" with "more inputs". More outputs with less inputs are easy and not really productive because it's possible via forcing labours to work more with less salary or outsourcing to China or India.

Create a culture: I thought Japan is quite unique.

Corporate tax breaks: Agree.

Pension payments: US-styled 401K is beneficial to financial companies, but not good for individuals. Japanese Social Insurance Agency is terrible, but Japan should improve it with maintaining its national pension scheme and raising sales tax.

Relax immigration: I'll pass on the debate.

Change election laws: Already changed, and thus more chaotic.
More lawyers: Parlty agree, but I assume that majority of Japanese don't like
Suing Society like USA.

I know that US-UK alliance works well because America is based on UK/EU culture, sharing the same values, but Japan-US alliance is very unique because almost all is different, Plus, our grandpa generation killed each other some 60 years ago. Japan-US alliance is virtually illusion.
 
Last edited:
After Cold War, Globalization prevails in terms of economy, but at the same time, it is more obvious to see Clash of Civilizations.

Japan-USA alliance has long worked so far, but this combination is most unlike because almost all elements of both countries are originally opposite.

Then China? I agree with Huntington on this point. Sinic is less similarity with Japan than USA/Europe.

Then Russian Orthodox as Huntington indicated? I happen to see beautiful Russian girls in Roppongi, but I am not familiar with Russia. Maybe good combination.
 
I personally reason that the only key to any form of a more productive and positive-in-outcome result for life on the planet (that means all life forms) is a balancing out of all things--as far as possible, within naturally set bounds. ①

Rather than focus on differences, we should make international efforts to focus on the similarities, and to even consider that among the various life forms. Therefore, we should work on building a more even, international culture which will take priority over and above regional cultures and sub-cultures.

This does not mean that we would forget, nor loose those latter, but simply our active culture, and/or our understanding of the international/multicultural culture, will be set in our minds so as to allow for it at all times, at any location on earth, without negative tags.

What should Japan do? The Japanese people as a whole, should join in, in working on that more profitable goal for future humanity and life forms. (and this is in no way insinuating anything about the whaling issue...)


① I say 'naturally set' because nature has developed some boundries which may never be over come, or at least may take a long time--such brain development levels among life forms, etc.
 
After Cold War ended, the world has become more diverse....

However, Japan remains unchanged - being relatively peacefully - because it
is less affected by external world.
Then why is it that so many people (largely the Japanese in power) complain that they are losing their identity and culture as a result of globalization?

Japan has changed quite a bit since the Cold War. It still has a long way to go, too.

Should Japan keep distance from the rest of thw world? or should open more?
Japan can't help but open more. It's all a matter of the rate at which it chooses to do so. Globalization will not stop. Just look internally, too, for a different reason. Declining birthrate. If Japan doesn't open its doors, it will die. Nobody will be around to work.

Isolationism hurt Japan in the past, and it will hurt even more in this fast-paced world if Japan decides to close itself off. It already has a bad reputation in the world of patent sharing and scientific credibility/creativity. Some Japanese Nobel laureates have criticized Japan for this openly, stating that Japan needs to open more.

I see this as a no-brainer.
 
There's definitely no going back, though I value Japan's ability to see and rely on a beautiful history. The future is within it's grasp and I think that Japan and it's people are making one of the most beautiful transitions! Japan is definitely a country of balance. I feel it and I see it. My students express it's importance. As for opening up, I cannot fathom the depth at which Japan is capable of accomplishing holistic goals. I admire Japan and it's dreams - especially the younger generation. I think the clash lies in expectations. And I wonder if perhaps, it is the West that must get a grip on things. I am no expert and my ideas change with time and experience. At this time. That is how I feel and see things.
 
There's definitely no going back.
But the reality is not what looks like.
1. Israeli troops invaded the Gaza Strip again, and Palestine conflict stick in the mud. Probably the worst ever. The West get stuck there.
2. Anglo-American global capitalism continues to sink (including Japan).
3. Russia-China-Iran takes more distance from the West.

In short, the world is moving towards "A World Without the West", and Japan is not a part of the West.
 
Last edited:


1 All I can say is huh? You have to remember, Japan, though not a Western country IMO, still has a strong capitalist system. Japan exports and imports and outsources to Thailand/Indonesia/China.

Has it fallen? I think it's more attention is now paid to the matter of scandals, and overcompensation to some top executives, regardless of the bottom-line results. Nothing that is going to bring the system down.

2 Uh, Japan recently seems to be floating more issues with this in the food industry, though China's dumpling (gyoza) woes have grabbed more of the headlines. Any country with weak intellectual property laws will have problems with counterfeit goods. Remember it was only 15 years or so ago that Japan didn't used to honor patents held outside of Japan!

3 Must agree, though some of it is fluff. There have always been conflicts, just more are emphasized with terrorist attacks now.

4. True, but more like one trading bloc, not necessarily a single country.

5(6). Russia has somewhat recovered, though it still has nice spats with its former regions.

However, Japan remains unchanged - being relatively peacefully - because it
is less affected by external world.

Political scientist Samuel P. Huntington, said JAPAN is uniquely developed civilization with its long history of consistency.

Could someone define what exactly the bolded part means?

Japan, considered a hybrid of Chinese civilization and older Altaic patterns.

In some cases, the Sinic, Hindu, Buddhist and Japonic civilizations are merged into a single civilization called Eastern World.

The above quotes are from the wiki link Astro gave. So perhaps the Japanese are more related to the Chinese than they care to admit?


In other words, regional powers such as the two Koreas and Vietnam will acquiesce to Chinese demands and become more supportive of China rather than attempting to oppose it.

I agree with the West's power declining, but you notice he doesn't mention capitalism per se.

Oh, oh, and since Japan has such 'good' relations with China, what do you think that will mean for Japan?



So, you have one theory, but nowhere does he talk about Japan not changing. If anything 3# is overstated, and Huntington's definitions and boundaries of cultures are being challenged.


In summary, Said argues that Huntington's view is flawed, as he is considering many countries as only a separate entity, rather than as part of a global culture. As to Japan's 'psychology', isolation is probably no longer an option. Look at what happened to N. Korea and Myanmar!
 
Has it fallen? I think it's more attention is now paid to the matter of scandals, and overcompensation to some top executives, regardless of the bottom-line results. Nothing that is going to bring the system down.

Scandals have nothing to do with fallen Capitalism. Resignation of NY governor has nothing to do with economic troubles in USA, either.


Pirate copy is not equal to copy. Without patent/loyalty fee is pirate copy.

Could someone define what exactly the bolded part means?

Greater line thickness represents more conflict in the civilizational relationship.
 
Scandals have nothing to do with fallen Capitalism. Resignation of NY governor has nothing to do with economic troubles in USA, either.

Well if they are financial scandals, they would have to do with your possible version of capitalism fallen. Unless N. Korea's economy took off and I didn't notice?

Pirate copy is not equal to copy. Without patent/loyalty fee is pirate copy.

Yes, and at one time in Japan they were copying designs blantantly and ignoring foreign patents. Sounds like a type of pirated copy to me.

GA posted
Could someone define what exactly the bolded part means?

Astroboy posted
Greater line thickness represents more conflict in the civilizational relationship.

I was referring to the following quote attributed to Hunington;

Political scientist Samuel P. Huntington, said JAPAN is uniquely developed civilization with its long history of consistency.

What consistency? And how is it that unique compared to the Chinese and Korean cultures it borrowed from?
 
Just look at the geography

Hi,

there have been pretty complex arguments here just to remind that Japan is a pretty isolated part of the world (just look at the map). It is also a mountainous country with no ressources that no sensible country would dare to invade (unless being attacked in the first place).

Apart from that, Japan is a country that has traditions that dates back centuries and tries to mix it with the modern world, just like most european and Asian countries.

It is also a country that tries to mix capitalism economy efficiency with its own traditions (capitalism is more linked to protestant way of thinking). Just like any catholic or muslim country in the world...
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…