This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

前の部分 / 願書を送る / という / 待っている

eeky

先輩
Joined
8 Jun 2010
Messages
2,431
Reaction score
22
Hi,


1. This is a note on the use of (このように/つまり)・・・(という)わけだ:

結論、まとめ : 前の部分が何を意味しているのかを 説明する

It looks to me as if the second part of this is ambiguous and can be read in two ways:

a) [前の部分]が[<implied subject>が何を意味しているのか]を[説明する]
b) <implied subject>が[前の部分が何を意味しているのか]を[説明する]

Are these both valid interpretations? I'm assuming (b) is the correct one in this case; is this right?


2. わたしは手紙で願書を送るよう決めた。

Translation given: "I wrote off for an application form."

I don't get this translation. I thought the sentence meant:

わたしは...送るよう決めた = I decided I would send
願書を = an application
手紙で = in the form of a letter

(i.e., in more natural English, "I decided to apply by letter".)


3. 海外旅行に行くといっても、二泊三日です。(山田さん のように1週間というわけではない。)

My translation: "Although I said that I'm going on an overseas trip, it's (only) for three days and two nights. I'm not going away for a whole week like Mr Yamada."

Is this correct? With という there, I wondered if the second sentence could mean "I'm not going away for a whole week like Mr Yamada said I was." (i.e. Mr Yamada made an incorrect statement).


4. 同じ年に入社したからといって、みんなが一緒に出世で きるというわけではない。彼らには厳しい競争が待って いるのだ。

My translation: "Just because they all joined the company at the same time doesn't mean they can all be promoted together. Intense competition awaits them."

Is this OK? Especially, have I interpreted 待っている correctly?
 
1.
Yes, (b) is correct. Though not 100% impossible, it is highly unlikely the sentence could mean (a) unless <implied subject> is a person, not a thing.

2.
Yes, your interpretation is correct.

3.
Your first translation is correct.
というわけ is a kind of set phrase, というわけではない can be translated as "(it is) not the case".

To make it means "I'm not going away for a whole week like Mr Yamada said I was.", you need to modify the sentence to something like
山田さんの言うように1週間というわけではない。


4.
Your translation is good and correct.
 
Hi undrentide, thanks for your help.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…