Help Difference between these grammatical constructions

alteregoivy

後輩
Joined
17 Jun 2009
Messages
15
Reaction score
0
I'm having trouble with expressions used to indicate things that occur at the same time.

First of all, what is the difference between ~うちに and ~際 ? Is it just that the first is used in more casual situations, and the second is used more formally?

Also, when using ~ところ/~ところに/~ところで/~ところを、how can you tell which particle needs to be used? I'm sure it's dependent on a clause in another part of the sentence, but I just can't figure it out.

Example practice sentences follow, I'll put in bold the right answer, which I basically got a 0% on.

大きいなあくびをしたところ(に・・が)写真に撮られた。
よく眠っているところ(に・・が)起こされた。
10ページ書き終わったところ(に・を・)、パソコンが動かなくなった。
引越しで忙しいところ(・で・は)、国から友達が遊びにきた。
テストの答えがわかったところ(に・・を)、終わりのバザーが鳴った。

Thank you!
 
what is the difference between ~うちに and ~際 ? Is it just that the first is used in more casual situations, and the second is used more formally?
~うちに is close to ~間に, not for "at a moment" but for "in/during a span."

涼しいうちに散歩してくる。
冷めないうちにお召し上がりください。

~際 is close to ~とき and mostly used for a concrete action.

こちらにお出での際は、是非お立ち寄りください。
×子供の際は、よく一緒に遊んでいた。
○子供のとき/頃は、よく一緒に遊んでいた。

A
Also, when using ~ところ/~ところに/~ところで/~ところを、how can you tell which particle needs to be used? I'm sure it's dependent on a clause in another part of the sentence, but I just can't figure it out.
Example practice sentences follow, I'll put in bold the right answer, which I basically got a 0% on.
大きいなあくびをしたところ(に・・が)写真に撮られた。
よく眠っているところ(に・・が)起こされた。
10ページ書き終わったところ(に・を・)、パソコンが動かなくなった。
引越しで忙しいところ(・で・は)、国から友達が遊びにきた。
テストの答えがわかったところ(に・・を)、終わりのバザーが鳴った。
That's a particle issue.

#1 the object of 撮られる
#2 when
#3,5 at the moment
#4 when/where
 
~うちに is close to ~間に, not for "at a moment" but for "in/during a span."
涼しいうちに散歩してくる。
冷めないうちにお召し上がりください。
~際 is close to ~とき and mostly used for a concrete action.
こちらにお出での際は、是非お立ち寄りください。
×子供の際は、よく一緒に遊んでいた。
○子供のとき/頃は、よく一緒に遊んでいた。
Thank you very much! I think I understand now.
That's a particle issue.
#1 the object of 撮られる
#2 when
#3,5 at the moment
#4 when/where
Ok... Then I think I need a recap on particles.

I thought that に is used for "when," rather than を, so I don't understand #2 still. Also, I still don't understand the difference between using で and に, as in between 3/5 and 4. Is で only ever used when the preceding verb is past tense (~ったところで)?
:sick:
 
No, no, sorry for my too much abridging.:p

I thought that に is used for "when," rather than を
Right. When a clause is nominalized by とき, the particle に is used.

10ページ書き終わったところで、パソコンが動かなくなった。
10ページ書き終わったときに、パソコンが動かなくなった。

You can think these ところ as "a scene/situation in an action/movement."
~ところを is close to ~のを, the verb used in the main clause expresses the action of the subject of the whole sentence. The all example sentences are the descriptions about "me." In #1 and 2, the subjects of 撮られる and 起こされる are "I," whereas the subjects in the main clases in #3~5 are not "I"(パソコン, 友達, ブザー).

~ところで emphasizes that it's "just at the moment" than ~ところに. The action/movement in the main clause is done just at the point in/right after the action/movement expressed in the ところ-clause.

~ところに is close to ~ときに. In #4, a friend came to me when I was busy, not just at the moment I was busy.

Is で only ever used when the preceding verb is past tense (~ったところで)?
No. You can use ところで in a conditional sentence, too.

これから勉強しようというところで遊びに来られると、 すごく困る。
 
Back
Top Bottom