travel guide for japan!

chabugarsh

後輩
Joined
12 Jan 2013
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
so my girlfriend and i made a video providing tons of information for anyone planning a trip to japan. i know there's alot to this country, and getting all the necessary info you need is a big hunt, so we decided to make it easier for anyone planning to go! Check out video out, and tell me what you think! if it's great, then like it, and if you think i left anything out, or had questions or anything, just leave a comment and i'll get to it! thanks :)
Preparing a Trip For Japan! - YouTube
 
I would really disagree with your opening statement in the video that says there isn't a lot of information out there all in one place.

Have you even looked at the Lonely Planet web site or guide book (or any other guide book, for that matter)? What was lacking?

You said the first step was to research the country itself.
ITEM 1 was "misconceptions".
Right away, this is something that not everyone needs to know.
Your first misconception was that people think the Japanese come off as rude. Huh? I've never heard that at all, before or after I traveled and lived here. In fact, most people will probably tell you their perception is that the Japanese are overly polite! You said they are very friendly and will go out of their way to help you. Well, yes, but not all the time. It also depends on the situation. If there is a language barrier, you might be stymied with no way to be helped. You said they are "appreciative" of the fact that foreigners would even attempt to speak Japanese. Not in my opinion and experience. They don't expect it, but they hope for it. And, when they hear it, they will compliment you, but that's all. And, no, they are NOT "very welcome and open" to foreigners. You are generalizing, and that's a problem.
Second misconception was "cleanliness". What??!?! Did you actually perceive Japan to be dirty until you came here? Again, never heard of that. Sushi chefs being clean is not fair to put in this vid. They HAVE TO BE clean.
Misconception 3. Japan is outrageously expensive. Well, yes. That's a thought, but to say "it's actually fairly cheap...it can be cheap" (and the woman cuts in and adds "be frugal"). C'mon, in what regard?
Misconception 4. Safety in Japan. what????? Who said Japan was NOT safe? You guys really got some strange info somewhere, and I know from my interests in the country beforehand that this was not how people think of the country.

And that was it for misconceptions? Wow. Nothing about the language barrier, koto music always playing in the background, everyone knowing martial arts, eating sushi daily, wearing kimonos daily. Those were some of the misconceptions I heard about a lot.

Preparing.
You admit that people plan differently, and that you spent 7 months planning (not everyone does), and that your trip was based around the order of things you wanted to buy. Right there, how does this help people who plan on sightseeing first? Or attending events? And did you actually think it was necessary to say that the first thing people should consider buying was a plane ticket??? How stupid to you think people are?
Your description of buying airline tickets left a LOT to be desired. Nuff said.

Lodging. Again, lacking in info.
No, ryokans are NOT "like bed and breakfasts"! And, they probably shouldn't be the FIRST place you mention for people. Your web sites for hostels didn't even include the top 2 for those in Japan! Your only salient point about hotels was that they are small, but to say that to get a room needs $500 a night is ludicrous. ("Don't expect anything too big unless you are willing to pay $500.")

Food. I stopped here, because you have obviously not even looked at a typical guide book. Airline tickets, lodging, and food are very commonly found in such things, as well as on any web site. This was a little more than half of your video at this point, so I thought it was useless to see what else you had "compiled". I didn't really see that the video solved anyone's problems about preparing. You were way to brief in your descriptions and left out a lot.
 
Do I understand correctly that you haven't actually made the trip yet? I would imagine a post-trip retrospective would be of more general and practical value to others.

Carol's a cutie!
 
Wait a minute. You haven't even come here and are giving this advice?

Nothing on passports, immigration's fingerprinting, money exchange, credit cards & carrying cash, taxes, tipping (lack thereof), taxis, subways, etc., but knowing you haven't even take the trip yet, I guess that's no surprise.

Oh, you might also want to reference LonelyPlanet.com and its Thorntree forum for a wealth of knowledge from fellow tourists and foreign residents.
 
Maybe they did. I can't tell yet for sure.

We get a plug at 14:54!
 
From the way they phrase things, they were still planning when they made the video.
 
Thanks for the criticism, the fact you really took time to dissect it really does help a ton. I know there was a TREMENDOUS amount of info not touched, but I felt as far as bare necessities go it was decent for most people who wanted quick insight on it. As far as the misconceptions go, I've gathered a lot of those ideas firsthand from people that come into my work (who travel heavily), or from other YouTube/blogs. And for preparing...you think that's all ridiculously simple tips, but you're assuming everyone would naturally think this way, which isn't true. Basically our info came from other people's experiences, along with our moderate amount of research, and I wish I could of put more in it, but I was avoiding making the video 30 minutes long lol...

---------- Post added at 21:43 ---------- Previous post was at 21:39 ----------

And thank you for reminding me of those other websites, ill definitely add an annotation for them! We will definitely be posting a post video so we can share OUR experience, but I felt like a very simple guide for any future japan chasers out there would be nice :).
 
You didn't want to make a really accurate (i.e., longer and more complete) video...why?

So, you complained openly that there wasn't a lot of information in one place, insinuated that you would provide that, and lied.

Your misconceptions, as I pointed out, are pretty bogus, so your associates clearly don't know what they were talking about, and you thereby spread false information by telling these to people.

As for "ridiculously simple tips", I only touched on one. The rest that I mentioned were outright badly done, and erroneous.

Moderate amount of research? You made a point of telling people not to go off half-cocked and that you spent 7 months researching (as an example of doing it better than others by "providing tons of information"), and now you refer to it as merely "moderate"? Geez. How much did you really want people to tune in to this and maybe a future blog just so you could make some money or gain some fame? Shame!
 
Frankly, the only really useful, practical, specific point I saw made was regarding the potential to save a few bucks with the JR Rail Pass. Then again, I think you would be hard pressed to really give much more without the benefit of the experience and perspective that will only be available to you after you see how well your preparation served you. By the way, while JR serves a very large part of Japan there are places served only by railroads other than JR and that pass won't help you if those are on your itinerary. So how much of a bargain the pass is can depend on just exactly where it is you intend to travel by rail. It is best to check beforehand and make sure whether the Rail Pass will get you there or if you're looking at buying tickets on another railroad (an added expense).

I also thought the misconceptions you addressed were so backwards to what I would expect them to be that I found myself wondering if you knew what "misconception" means. But I've been away for a while and I suppose it is possible that a different (and seemingly polar opposite) set of misconceptions has arisen.

On a mild tangent, I would like to point out that if you try to fit too much of Japan into a trip you can end up spending so much time on trains and in train stations that you don't have time to see or enjoy the places you dash around to, going home with mostly memories of train interiors and station platforms. A whole lot of Japan looks just like any other part of Japan, especially if you've never been here and have only a limited time available to you. Unless you have some specific must-see destinations in mind for different cities you can find yourself dashing about to look at a city that looks just like the city you just left.
 
One would think that anyone even contemplating doing a travel guide (video or otherwise) would go to Japan first and then attempt it. Doing so before you've even stepped foot on Japanese soil is putting the cart before the horse.
 
Back
Top Bottom