- 4 Sep 2015
- 2,306
- 1,906
So you're not going to post your work on last week's lesson and let us help you get that down?
What is the name of the book? We may be able to find a pdf of it online.
Is it going to be an every week thing that you post questions on Saturday and can't check for replies until the following Tuesday? We've done this twice in a row now. Frankly, I'm not going to bother trying to rush answers to you hours ahead of your lesson if I know you're not going to see them until days after the lesson and even then just totally ignore the replies trying to help you with what you asked about and not bother to show your work or give any indication whatsoever that this whole studying Japanese thing has crossed your mind at all any other time than just before class, when you apparently give it a quick look in hopes of not embarrassing yourself in class. I'll bust a gut to help anybody who's giving it a serious effort and working with me, but I won't lift a finger to help anybody who is half-ässing and who gives me the impression I'm taking their problem more seriously than they are themselves. And so far that's the impression I get.
So you're not going to post your work on last week's lesson and let us help you get that down?
What is the name of the book? We may be able to find a pdf of it online.
Is it going to be an every week thing that you post questions on Saturday and can't check for replies until the following Tuesday? We've done this twice in a row now. Frankly, I'm not going to bother trying to rush answers to you hours ahead of your lesson if I know you're not going to see them until days after the lesson and even then just totally ignore the replies trying to help you with what you asked about and not bother to show your work or give any indication whatsoever that this whole studying Japanese thing has crossed your mind at all any other time than just before class, when you apparently give it a quick look in hopes of not embarrassing yourself in class. I'll bust a gut to help anybody who's giving it a serious effort and working with me, but I won't lift a finger to help anybody who is half-ässing and who gives me the impression I'm taking their problem more seriously than they are themselves. And so far that's the impression I get.
We all understand that you're in special circumstances due to your recent life upheaval. If you don't have internet access from Saturday afternoons until Tuesdays, we can understand that and work around it...but if that is the case and you want help previewing your upcoming Saturday lesson, then please post it earlier in the week so you can actually see replies and be helped by them before class. Your textbook really isn't a very good one for your circumstances, but we can work around that.
Did you already do book 1?
They are for the most part kind of blurry. Sadly, as you have indicated, the instructions and explanations range from crappy to non-existent, don't they? I looked it up online and learned it was put together by a well-meaning group of local volunteers and makes absolutely no use of any standard curriculum.
日本語教育コンテンツ共有システム
I don't have the power to correct anything around here....or anywhere else either, come to think of it.
I never thought I would ever direct anyone to Tae Kim's Japanese grammar guide, but we're going to need some kind of existing explanation in English to keep us from essentially having to type up an English version of your lessons from scratch. You can check for explanations from Tae Kim and we can help you with whatever remains unclear after that.
http://www.guidetojapanese.org/grammar_guide.pdf
Save it to your computer so you can use it offline too.
OK, I see the problem, it is invisible. It's in the center between post reply and more options.
Got it now. Here are the pages of lesson 5. Mike I now will be able to post a picture of my work on lesson 4 and I do have a comment on what the teacher said. I was without internet for the last several days as I mention so now I'll catch up on my past post for assistance on lesson 4. Again, thanks Mike.
Dialogue Comprehension Exercise
1. マリリンさんは、なにをかいにきましたか。
ジョギングシューズです
2. マリリンさんは、どんないろのくつをはいてめましたか。
あかいです。
3. まりりんさんは、なぜジョウギングシューズをかいませんでしたか。
またこんどにします
Thanks, folks
Typo marked in red.
While your answers on 1 and 2 aren't technically incorrect, you should try answering using the lesson's target grammar point. Hint: the bulk of the answer is in the question. Largely a matter of simple substitution.
For 3.... read the dialogue again and see if you can spot why she didn't buy the shoes.
Typo marked in red.
While your answers on 1 and 2 aren't technically incorrect, you should try answering using the lesson's target grammar point. Hint: the bulk of the answer is in the question. Largely a matter of simple substitution.
For 3.... read the dialogue again and see if you can spot why she didn't buy the shoes.
Hope this is right.
1. マリリンさんは、なにをかいにきましたか。
ジョギングシューズです
ジョキングシュズかいてです。
2. マリリンさんは、どんないろのくつをはいてめましたか。
あかいのくつです。
3. まりりんさんは、なぜジョウギングシューズをかいませんでしたか。
ちょうとちいさいです。
Are these correct now?
ジョキングシュズかいてです。
ジョキングシュズかいくてです。
ちょうとちいさいです。
ちょっとちさいので。
Are these OK now?
I noticed the め should be み。
Thanks, Mike.
マリリンさんは、なにをかいにきましたか。
マリリンさんは、どんないろのくつをはいてめましたか
Is there any reason you put から before の?4. これはどこのお金ですか。 ちゅうごくkaraのです
5. これはどこのワインですか。フランスからのです
On number 4 and 5,are thoset correct?
No, not at all.
I said the underlined parts should be in your answers. They're not in your answers at all.
マリリンさんはジョギングシューズをかいにきました。
マリリンさんはあかいくつをはいてみました。
ちいさい not ちさい
Do you understand the " verb stem + ni ikimasu (kimasu)" construction and what it means?
Do you understand how to form verb stems?
To form verb stems, you essentially just cut the "-masu" off of polite verb forms.
Tabemasu -- tabe
Nomimasu -- nomi
Yomimasu -- yomi
Shimasu -- shi
These grammatically function as nouns. Add "ni ikimasu" and it means "go to do xxx". Add "ni kimasu" and it means "come to do xxx".
So かいにきます is "come to buy" and かいにきました is the past tense of that.
Did you recognize きました as being past tense? I get the feeling there are some verb conjugation basics that were covered in Book 1 which maybe you didn't get. You need to go back and make sure you have a grasp of all the stuff in Book 1 or you're going to get more and more befuddled as things go along.
Read section 4.1 of Tae Kim:
4.1 Polite Form and Verb Stems
You should have repeated the class for Book 1 instead of taking the class for Book 2. This is the largest part of your trouble and why you feel the class is bewilderingly fast. The other students are having an easier time mainly because they learned the material in Book 1 first, not because they're enrolled in the university.
As you get to an intermediate or advanced level, it doesn't matter very much in what order you learn many new things. But due to the very regular and methodical way Japanese builds structures with verbs and adjectives....much like Lego blocks or snapping various handles, adapters, extensions, and sockets together with socket wrenches...it is absolutely essential that one learn well the basics of how to manipulate the basic building blocks. That's the foundation for everything that comes later. And in the later classes they will just assume you already know well the material covered in the earlier classes and spend zero time explaining the stuff you are already supposed to know.
If the class for Book 1 is currently being offered, I would strongly suggest asking your teacher if you can change your class to that one. I have no idea what is in Book 1, but it was enough to make a course text out of it and is stuff that they assume you already know in the class for Book 2. Unless you go back and learn the material in Book 1, you're just going to get more and more lost, more and more confused, and find it harder and harder to follow anything going on in class as the weeks go by. Each new lesson will be using things from earlier lessons, which you will not have learned yet, and the whole thing is going to rapidly snowball into an avalanche of frustration. Japanese isn't a subject where you can jump into it somewhere in the middle and expect to catch up or keep up.
There's no shame in having to repeat a class. Hell, I flunked the first Japanese class I ever took.