Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
paradoxbox said:I find it a little hard to believe that one would see SO MANY incidents on a train in such a short period of time.
A common explanation of this phenomenon is that, with others present, observers all assume that someone else is going to intervene and so they each individually refrain from doing so. This is an example of how diffusion of responsibility leads to social loafing. People may also assume that other bystanders may be more qualified to help, such as being a doctor or police officer, and their intervention would thus be unneeded. People may also fear "losing face" in front of the other bystanders, being superseded by a "superior" helper, or offering unwanted assistance. Another explanation is that bystanders monitor the reactions of other people in an emergency situation to see if others think that it is necessary to intervene. Since others are doing exactly the same, everyone concludes from the inaction of others that other people do not think that help is needed. This is an example of pluralistic ignorance and social proof. An alternative to explanations of rational motivation is that emotional cues to action can be as powerful as rational ones, and the presence of a group of inactive others is a pre-rational emotional cue to inaction that must be overcome.
Serpico, what you say is true...but don't forget this happens not only in Japan, and not EVERYWHERE in Japan.And not EVERY Japanese person is like this.That's where you are wrong in your thinking.I went to Hokkaido last xmasvacation and didn't have any bad experiences, people were friendly to me, and helped me when I needed something.I think in the Japanese society it's a bit normal to be selfish, the society is not easy to live in.In the future please think about the good also, and don't just rant about the bad !
(A gaijin traveller said so in some documenatry I saw..that's my source..)
If I remember right, he was travelling around japan for a month and visited/interviewed several different people from different backgrounds and places so it was a good documentary. The people in Hokkaido shared their stories (other travellers) adn they all agreed that the people in Hokkaido are more tolerant to stangers then theny are in the mainland.Who spent how long in Japan? Had been where in Japan? Had done what in Japan? Its just one person as well, I'd take anything I saw with a grain of salt and consider it to be unique and not average or normal.
The phenomena that a man or woman who is in trouble in a train or bus but no one comes to help, can be found mostly in big cities. But I think those passengers and bystanders are indeed bad educated people, who might have been well educated about career and not losing the face instead of being kindly and ready to help your other citizens.
The behavior is mostly bounded to the society you live. The more people in a society/place live, the more anonymious the people become where nobody greets anyone, unlike in the more calm and rural places.
I think in most world's societies, it is time to re-invent "social behavior" at the schools to teach the kids about respect, braveness, brotherly love and the will to help others.
Think, there are reasons for people not assisting others. Once there was a time, and to many people I know still now to this day as well, from what I was told since coming to live here, that if someone helped out a person who was let's say bleeding or dying whatever. (Something that any "average" westerner would run to help with) and per chance the person died the "HELPER" could be found liable as well for the persons death.
Too late.my point is dont lump all japanese people in the same category
doing this may make people think you are an ignorant naive racist
the troll said:I am not bitter about that
Again you think calling an entire country's worth of men as maliciously intentioned rapists and slave drivers as somehow emotionally and mentally balanced?. If anything mate, the only one in a fantasy world is you.Don't try to psycho analyze me until you know the whole story. Don't read in things that are not there. If you think Japan is a perfect place, good for you. Go on living in your fantasy world. Leave the worlds problems for the grown ups.
And where, praytell, is your almighty good samaritan attitude when third world children are starving to death? why do you chose to rant insultingly about Japan instead of going off to an african country and helping the really needy?.If you are too cowardly to address a problem and choose to sweep it under the rug, then you certainly wouldn't have the minimal human decency to help a needy stranger.
mycernius said:I am a hairy foreigner. -Wookies Rule-
I agree you shouldn't be censored. You point of view is just as valid as the next mans. As I said the only problem I had with your posts was the way they were written. I felt as if you were shouting them at me and not even going to take in account of what other people thought. I do agree that Japan suffers from racism and the people do seem to have a hive mentality. It could have been put across better than the original posts.
I should also point out you are in a foreign country and the morals and society of other countries are different to your own.
But I want to thank Japan for giving me lots of material for my book. I dont even have to do too much research. Just living my life here is giving me tons of material which would shock most Americans into changing their buying patterns
you can't just rip on someone just because you don't like their customs.
I remember when i lived in Hiroshima and got sick of hanging in foreigner bars and started to search out places "where no (foreign)man has gone before...". One night i found a dingy basement club and they had a huge group of reggae lovers and live DJ's spinnin' vinyl...all Japanese reggae mind you! very impressive it was.
Well, i was the only non-japanese there...had a good time despite being ignored as if i were a ghost...all university/college kids too...now in this kind of place and event no point in trying to meet girls 'cause they're all together with friends and will never consider risking the stigma of leaving with a white guy...or even chatting it seemed...
in this kind of place many times i ended up being spoken to by similairly out of place Japanese older guys who were quite friendly...
what's my point? well, i guess it's better to risk being ignored in a COOL bar than to hang with (mostly) white guys who are complaining (i.e. dissatisfied with jobs, isolation, marginalisation) AND competing for the far less than average girls in the place...
Seriously, there is nothing wrong with drinking and hanging out and meeting people, but it is very hard to defend oneself from the sexfiend image others may choose to project on you WHEN most of the guys around are pushing the limit to get into a girls ***. i just avoid the possibility 'cause i need people to know i'm respectable, so can't give the weak minded a chance to judge me simply by where i am or the others around me...this is extremely important and it IS a kind of impression management that i don't really care to take part in...unavoidable in most situations i'm afraid.
It's a small thing what people think...i know, but still i feel it is an effort to help others not to be judgemental or narrow minded...
when you stand out in a crowd or where ever you go, it is inevitable that you will start to care more than you might normally about the impact on others. everyone wants and deserves to be liked and accepted. personally, as a white guy, i am sad to feel the need to have to distance myself from others like me because of their selfish behavior...
actually i've got it real good here in Japan...great new HOUSE. great stereo. 3 cool cars and a Ducati...great country roads and hotsprings within minutes of home...i just got no time for messed up people who outta really head back to their respective homelands and give up their useless struggle 'cause they won't never get it straight...