News Controversy over Nagoya Castle and access for the disabled

thomas

Unswerving cyclist
Admin
Joined
14 Mar 2002
Messages
21,050
Reaction score
18,903
For a long time, Nagoya Mayor Takashi Kawamura has dreamed of restoring the castle's keep with wood, following its original design. However, his insistence on an "original" and "authentic" Nagoya Castle has caused much controversy. The historic Nagoya Castle is facing a new challenge, this time from those who want to make it more wheelchair-friendly and those who wish to preserve it as it was.

A heated argument broke out at a public meeting on the castle's renovation on 3 June when a man berated a wheelchair user. "You are being selfish, not equal," the man said. "How can you be so selfish." The rude words were directed at a 70-year-old man with a disability who asked for an elevator to be installed in the city's landmark castle.


nagoya-castle-disabled-access.webp


To make it a tourist attraction, the castle needs to meet modern earthquake and fire standards, which require technologies that were unavailable when the original castle was built in the 17th century. In addition, with or without an elevator, the original designs of the castle will inevitably need to be altered to accommodate emergency exits and other regulatory requirements. "It's an illusion to believe that you can reconstruct a truly 'authentic' Nagoya Castle," said Yoshihiro Senda, a professor of castle archeology at Nagoya City University. Senda criticizes the mayor's apparent double standard about what constitutes a historically "authentic" building. "Why can modern technologies be used to make the castle tourist-friendly but not to make it accessible to all?" Senda said. The Cultural Affairs Agency said a reconstructed Nagoya Castle would be considered a replica rather than a cultural treasure, even if it is rebuilt exactly to the original design specifications. It will be classified as a public facility, like a history museum that serves the purpose of promoting culture and tourism, said the agency. People with disabilities and their supporters want an elevator installed in the castle because a new keep, which will cost 50.5 billion JPY (USD 344 million) of taxpayers' money, should be a public property of the community.




Nagoya Castle

Castle  Nagoya Castle

Nagoya Castle (名古屋城 Nagoya-jō) ranked among the three greatest Japanese castles and was built after the Battle of Sekigahara (1600) by Tokugawa Ieyasu as a defence against the Toyotomi who still had held significant power. Ieyasu appointed his son Yoshinao (徳川義直, 1601-1650), the founder of the...

Nagoya Castle

Castle  Nagoya Castle

Tokugawa Ieyasu built Nagoya Castle (名古屋城 Nagoya-jō) in 1609-14 on the site of a smaller castle taken over and renamed by Oda Nobunaga’s father, Oda Nobuhide (織田信秀, 1510-1551). The castle was abandoned by the Oda clan in 1582 and reconstructed by the victorious Ieyasu to ensure the security of...
 
Back
Top Bottom