Official Recognition-Maciamo

[Index]

It seems your ideas about Japan are spreading beyond the forum Maciamo-one of my postgraduate students has used you as a reference in her essay about Japan-China relations. I'm just not sure what I should say to her...

 

[nice gaijin]

that's a dilly of a pickle!

 

[Mike Cash]

It seems your ideas about Japan are spreading beyond the forum Maciamo-one of my postgraduate students has used you as a reference in her essay about Japan-China relations. I'm just not sure what I should say to her...

That she may as well have used Wikipedia references?

 

[Index]

That she may as well have used Wikipedia references?

Luckily that was the only one that was somewhat lacking in academic rigour (no offence to Maciamo, but I mean neither peer reviewed nor a primary source).

I give grave warnings about Wikipedia but nonetheless they still creep in there every now and then.

 

[pipokun]

She might be a great student if she made her own research on the editing war on Wiki.

 

[MajideSaiaku]

Using Maciamo as a source is just poor (sorry Mac, no offense, but your not a legitimate source for essay's).

You should just remind her of good research and sourcing and that the bias opinions of one person doesnt constitute legitimate sourcing.