This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

Help with using ni

wizcoder

後輩
Joined
4 Jul 2014
Messages
108
Reaction score
4
Hi,
So I know you use に when it comes to movement or describing where you are going or where you went.
In example I would recognize any sentence like this.
わたしはきょうとにいきました。
たけしさんもきょうとにいきました。
Where I am in the book, a question like this appears:
あなたのまちににほんのレストランがありますか
And it translate to "Do you have a japanese restaurant in your city/town".
What I don't understand is why is に used after "city" because nothing in the sentence is about travelling somewhere or going to a location but rather asking about a place in the city.
The other examples also use に after each place but I don't see why and in the book they say they will further discuss the に but I haven't seen the meaning other from what they told me. The books exact words "The particle に has many meanings, but here we will learn two: (1) the goal toward which things move, and (2) the time at which an event takes place."
Why is it used during a question but not to go somewhere?
 
Sounds like you're using Genki. Look at page 77, it's explained there:

Note that あります is different from other verbs we have seen so far. It calls for the particle に, rather than で, for the place description.

So indeed, *normally* で is used for things that happen at a location while に is for things that go toward a location, but います/あります make an exception. They use に to indicate the location even though the action consists of merely being present there.
 

Found it, thanks alot!
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…