This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

Obese China

Maciamo

先輩
Twenty-year veteran
Joined
17 Jul 2002
Messages
5,907
Reaction score
385
BBC News : China warned of obesity time-bomb


So who said that Orientals were genetically predisposed to be thin ? If most Japanese, and indeed most East Asians are thin nowadays, it may be due to 2 factors : healthy food (in Japan), frugality due to economic conditions (in most other countries). Interestingly, the obesity rate in China is increasing at the same speed as the economy (8% per year).

Chinese food is notoriously fat. With the rise of the Chinese economy, it is only natural that people eat more, work less physically (more office work instead of manual labour) and thus more fat people. What surprises me is that people in Singapore and Hong Kong, who are also Chinese eating mostly Chinese food, do no get fatter. Maybe, like in the US, it is matter of poorer education in Mainland China. People might not eat equilibrated anymore, or become excessive by lack of self-control (often due to a sense of deprivation).

The perenial question is, why are Americans in average so much fatter than Europeans, and why would the Chinese become so much fatter than the Japanese ? Food diversity ? Lifestyle ? I refuse to think it is sport/exercise, as American people are usually much more sport-obssessed than Europeans and Japanese people. Could it just be a psychological difference ? But what do the younger Chinese share in common with the Americans than they do not share with the Japanese ? Quiz time !
 
For one I think that it is the Chinese diet being much more fatty. With an increase in income and the expanding economy, maybe the Chinese are doing less manual labor and have more money to spend on food vs 10-20 yrs ago. Therefore, with less work and more money to spend on food, their high fat diet is finally beginning to show. Just a guess.

In Japan I have noticed that the younger generation is much fatter than they were a generation ago. However, it seems that once they get into adulthood, vanity and common sense takes over as they want to be attracted by, and to, the opposite sex. Also their diet is much more healthier with less fat and more protein.

I don't know much about the Chinese lifestyle, but the Japanese do seem to walk alot during their daily routine. Even myself, when I lived in Japan I did much more walking to the train station, work, combini, etc., than I ever do here in the US as I need my car to go anywhere. For me to walk, I have to force myself to do it around the neighborhood.

Americans are fatter than the Europeans because they eat too much! Eating has become a hobby here and there is no regard to nutritional content whatsoever.

You are wrong in your assessment that the Americans are much more sport-obsessed than European or Japanese people. Americans, for the most part are down right lazy and they eat way too much junk food. Exercise to them is a dirty word and involves too much work. It may seem that they are sport-obsessed in places like California or New York and such where vanity and "looking good" are the lifestyle. And they are.

But take a visit outside those places to the heartland and you will notice that more than 60-70% of the population is overweight. A car is needed to go anywhere. Americans work too much, thus they eat alot of fast food and there is no time for exercise because watching the latest reality show is more important. No one walks at all. All you can eat Chinese food restaurants are always packed and there is a long wait for a seat. Burger chains and restaurants are promoting that they have the biggest burger and larger portions and such. You can double your portion of fries and drink for 30 cents more! 2 for 1 pizza is a tradition on the weekends "with more cheese and toppings than the competitor." Drive by any fast food chain in the evening and there will be a long line of cars waiting for the drive through. Therefore, the average American is severely under nourished in the amount of fiber, protein, vegetables and vitamins they consume. In America, for the most part, it is not the quality of the food, but the quantity and "how much food can I get for my dollar?" The government recently announced that there is an epidemic of obesity in the US. An epidemic!

Thus the younger Chinese share the same thing in common with Americans. A high fat diet with little or no exercise and money to spend on food. Much like the younger Japanese without the fatty food but a high intake of junk food.
 
Well, it's obvious there's has to be some sort of lifestyle changes. So, I guess I was right, chinese food being non-fatty is a myth. The obesity problem in America has do with us needing discipline. But, I mean really? I wouldn't say that Americans hate exercising, I would argue the point that we don't have much time for it. However, Americans really need to stop giving into those advertisments for increase in quantities of food. That's why I get angry when I see people trying to sue the fastfood industry for the reasons why they're overwieght. For of all, it's NOT the fastfood industry's fault you're obese, it's your fault for not choosing to eat properly. Besides, there's no excuse as to why Americans can't healthier. kashii:

I don't know the situation with China or Japan. I just hope it doesn't get out of hand like it has here in the States.
 
I wonder if there's any connection between a decrease in home-cooked meals and an increase in obesity. Adding to the too busy idea, perhaps people just don't have time to cook anymore. I have no idea whether there's any connection -- I'm just throwing out ideas.
 
You are correct in your assessment about discipline. But most of the people I know hate exercising and will do anything to not do it thus they don't. Of course I know a couple who do it religiously, but for the most part they hate it. But you are correct in that they don't have much time for it with all their work and such. I'm with you in the suits against the fast food industry. It's their fault and they should have more discipline. In my case I had to cut down my eating to twice a day. With my age and slower metabolism, I just had to do do it as my weight went up to almost 180 lbs. I just cut out one meal, all soft drinks and candy and sugary substances, eat healthier and take suppliments. Now my weight is down to a respectable 160 lbs.

I believe there is a connection. With both parents working to pay the mortgage, cable, cell phone, cars, HDTV bills and such they don't have time to cook a healthy meal for the kids. So they just slap something together or order fast food with no nutrition whatsoever. When I was a kid, mom didn't need to work to pay the bills and we always had a home-cooked health meal with vegetables and such. Today, that is quite rare.
 
I think there might be a connection; as far as I recall there are numerous breakfast cafeterias where they serve quick meals quite early in the morning. I used to get soft tofu and soy sauce or hundun (wonton) soup. I don't know if they are still popular, but if so, that's another common aspect between the US and China.

One thing that comes to mind is China's low reliance on rice. I think the heavy reliance on rice in Japan and Korea is widely different from the variety of staples in the diets of US and China where there isn't such a strong preference for rice. I really don't know how else this might be related to obesity per se though. It might be that their diet is somewhat healthier because it's more diversified ?
 
BTW Lexico, what is the situation in Korea with obese people? Do they eat similar to Japanese or Chinese? Is the younger generation obese? I only visited Korea once and I thought they ate similar to Japanese with the exception of kimchi. However, in my in-laws house kimchi is a staple food eaten everyday for it's health benefits. I wonder how many JApanese households eat kimchi on a regular basis?
 
That home cooked meal argument makes sense. Then again, there could be alot of reasons for the obesity problem. These days, food is being processed instead being natural.
 
Ma_Cherie said:
These days, food is being processed instead being natural.
In my opinion, that is the biggest problem. Processed food! :bikkuri:
 
I would say the diet here is closer to Japanese than it is to Chinese; rice and kimchi is THE staple diet. Obesity has been on the rise; it has become a serious problem for some people ast least. I think it's related to the change in diet that some poeple believe is acceptable now. Many mothers are either too busy to cook for their children, or don't have the inclination to cook. Some mothers are into thinking what they find decent food is okay for their kids. Very unscientific thinking wouuld explain a lot of what's going on; poor kids who have to suffer for their mothers not knowing much in terms of food and health.

As for kimchi in the average Japanese household, I don't have any stats, but I've noticed some Japanese visiting Korea on business make it a point to shop for kimchi for their wives back home. So I'd say it's become quite popular in Japan.
 
It seems that this has become the norm in almost all industrialized countries although I don't know about Europe. They think that just because it's advertised on TV that it is ok to eat and feed ones children. But when you do a little further reasearch you find that there is absolutely little or no nutritional value whatsoever in some of the meals people are eating these days. Quite sad. The least they could do is fortify their meals with suppliments to keep their immune system functioning properly.
 

This is interesting. I had suspected that this might be the case, but I never had any hard evidence that it could be:

http://www.frenchcreoles.com/foods.htm

More info on rice production in the US:
http://www.riceromp.com/teachers/lessonContent.cfm?pId=78
The states with the highest rice consumption are Hawaii and Louisiana.

I can't seem to find any figures, but the point remains that somewhere it's documented that rice consumption in Louisiana is higher than nearly all of the rest of the nation. Unfortunately for us, though, it doesn't outweigh the other factors of obesity.

http://www.lpb.org/programs/LApublicsquare/topic009.html

Anyway, the point of all of this was to show that reliance on rice isn't inversely proportionate to obesity.

It appears that rice consumption is a factor in the Japanese's slimness, but they also eat a lot of other healthful foods, and there seems to be a nationwide obsession with phys. ed. (at least while in school). We, however, love our butter and fat, and don't excersice very much, hence the obesity problem.
 
Most probably there is a connection. AFAIK, the obesity problem in China is most prevalent among youngsters which habitually eat at McDonald's or similar restaurants. The traditional Chinese diet is not to blame, I think. It's by far not as healthy as many Chinese seem to think, but it doesn't really lead to obesity.

Another reason for obesity in China may be the one-child policy. Many Chinese kids are simply spoilt.


lexico said:
One thing that comes to mind is China's low reliance on rice.
To me as a German Chinese food culture seems to focus very much on rice (although there is an incredible number of Chinese dishes without rice), it's definitely the Chinese staple food no.1.
Is rice so much more prevalent in Korea & Japan that it makes China's reliance on rice look comparatively low?
 
lexico said:
As for kimchi in the average Japanese household, I don't have any stats, but I've noticed some Japanese visiting Korea on business make it a point to shop for kimchi for their wives back home. So I'd say it's become quite popular in Japan.

I confirm that kimchi is becoming quite popular in Japan. My wife and I just love it. Whenever I pass through Incheon Airport, I see loads of Japanese buying kimchi as "omiyage". In fact, the Korean staff selling it greet customers in Japanese assuming only Japanese will buy it at the airport !
 

There is a big gap between North and South China regarding rice consumption. Most Chinese restaurants in Western countries are the Southern type, with mostly rice. I noticed that Chinese restaurants in Japan, and especially expensive ones, mainly serve fried rice as the last dish of a long course, with no rice during the rest of the course. Chinese food in Japan means more "men" (–Ë), gyoza (éLŽq), shoronpo, nikumanjuu ("÷é\"ª), etc.
 
well 1 thing they are getting more fat is because a lot of Chinese youth make instant noodles and go to KFC/Mc Donalds ALLLLL the time...sometimes they are just too lazy to make food so they choose the FASTFOOD way, especially when the exams are coming... :souka:
 
Maciamo said:
There is a big gap between North and South China regarding rice consumption.
That's true, actually. Most of my Chinese friends are from the South, therefore I may have a certain prejudice. I stand corrected (although, from a German perspective, even the North Chinese still seem to eat a large amount of rice).

Anyway, I don't think that either Southern or Northern Chinese suffer from obesity due to their traditional cuisine. It's probably mostly fast food with a certain lack of physical activity that does it.
 
This will also not help China if it hopes to be a first world superpower:


Gotta love the honesty of the Chinese government. I'd post the link to this article, but it doesn't work anymore.
 
Within 20 years, China could have the majority of all smoking deaths in the world.E......The number of Chinese smokers is growing by three million a year, despite an estimated 1.3 million tobacco-related deaths annually.
Interesting article. This should've been it's own thread though as there will probably be many comments on it. Anyway, referring to the quotes above, with the severe over population in China, and their having one-sixth of the world's population, maybe this is their way of reducing the population. Just a thought.
 
I like the humor which I can resonate. As for your last comment, I'd like to give my favorite quote from myself.
That deadly thing ought to be reduced. The enlightened ones must take the lead.
I always knew that it helped sustain my emotional harmony; but now I know it helps to prevent a plethora of obscure physical illnesses as well. Perhaps scientists should study new ways to deliver health benefits via the fuming medium ? One scary possibility would be the control over smokers by the smoke manufacturers ? Am I sedated ??? :?
 
Last edited:
Its possible that with all of the 'Fast foods' available that over consumption of such can cause obesity, I also think that the amount of chemicals/hormone drugs pumped into animals bred for consumption have something to do with this. Because of overpopulation there is a larger need for more beef, chicken etc... and to cater for these extra people the battery farms are needing to pump out more meat, and a lot faster too, hence the reason why they see fit to use hormones. Surely these hormones are beefing up the people eating the meat? I dont have any quotes to back me up, its just my thinking.... and not necessarily aimed at china, sort of a world wide epidemic creeping up. Just when I was in New Zealand we noticed that the younger generation eat a lot more KFC, and the girls seem to be 'developing' alot faster.
 
cicatriz esp said:
This will also not help China if it hopes to be a first world superpower:



Gotta love the honesty of the Chinese government. I'd post the link to this article, but it doesn't work anymore.
yeah I saw it posted on a Chinese board yesterday !! In my opinion it's the biggest load of crap just to keep people smoking.
 
cicatriz esp said:
Gotta love the honesty of the Chinese government. I'd post the link to this article, but it doesn't work anymore.
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/LAC.20050611.CHINA11/BNStory/Idx/

You cut off a bit at the end, as it seems:

"The student's uncle, who had smoked for 30 years, died of lung cancer in February. To spare his feelings, his family had never told him the truth about his illness.

"I was shocked," Mr. Li said. "The government should be doing more. We need promotion campaigns to tell people about it.""


Now that is interesting, when I try to reach the page via the above link in the forum, it doesn't work. The same URL via Google works (but not the cached page). :? There is some secret technology I don't understand at work. For all those who want to read the article, I suggest to use Google instead of my link (or you could register for free with globeandmail).
 
I think everyone here knows that smoking is harmful to health, including my 11 year old niece, she has known that for quite a few years. Who would believe smoking is great for health?
bossel said:
"The student's uncle, who had smoked for 30 years, died of lung cancer in February. To spare his feelings, his family had never told him the truth about his illness.
This is a familiar phenomenon, when someone got a incurable disease, his or her family might choose not telling the truth, they thought that would keep the patient in good mood thus the patient could live a little longer, usually the patient would figure out finally.
 
Americans are fatter than the Europeans because they eat too much! Eating has become a hobby here and there is no regard to nutritional content whatsoever.
In America, their fast food is cheap so people buy more and donft bother to cook. In France for example if you go to eat at a fast food joint or if you go eat in a traditional restaurant, fast food is not cheaper and people prefer to eat their traditional French food rather than junk.
If Chinese in China are getting fat it must be them copying the American way of life. The last time I checked people of China admired America. They love Disneyland, McDonalds coca cola, star buckscetc.
I donft think having a traditional Chinese diet is fattening. It depends on what you eat, there are high fat ones and there are low fat ones. If you want to stay slim stick with foods that are steam, braise, boil and a bit of stir fry is ok. If you like to eat food that is fried, deep fried and majority of your diet consists of those you are likely to be fat. But there is also metabolism rate and lifestyle. People in Taiwan, Hong Kong, Singaporecetc walk a lot to work, study and they work on weekends too. However eating high fat foods in moderation with a healthy lifestyle of physical activity such as walking will not get you fat.
Is rice so much more prevalent in Korea & Japan that it makes
China's reliance on rice look comparatively low?
Actually the Southern Chinese have strong reliance on rice, the northerners eat noodles and Chinese steamed bread. But this is not the cause I think, it is the American fast-food industries that is spreading in China.
Kim Chi is just one of the items brought by the Korean wave that is very popular among not just Japanese but East Asians in general at the moment. I like Kim chi, but I like it because it taste good to me I am not following any trend or anything.
Yep, thatfs true.
Anyway, I don't think that either Southern or Northern Chinese suffer from obesity due to their traditional cuisine. It's probably mostly fast food with a certain lack of physical activity that does it.
Yes that is what I am thinking as well.
On the subject of smoking I donft smoke but a lot of my family members do for some reason.
 
Last edited:
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…