This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

be it

nekocat

先輩
Joined
3 Apr 2007
Messages
265
Reaction score
11
tintin said:
You do as you like! But on your own head be it if we have trouble from this scorpion, Wolff! I disclaim all responsibility!
What on earth does "be it" here mean? Is it an idiom or a present subjunctive?
 
It's another way to say, "It will be on your own head if we have trouble from this scorpion, Wolff!"
 
Nekocat, are you reading a lot of classic literature...? This might not be the best representation of modern colloquial English, though I applaud your interest, especially in novels like Frankenstein, which sort of get short shrift due to their popularity in pop-culture, but there are very many subtle metaphors to that book.
 
'On your head be it' is an idiom which means 'the responsibility for the result of that action or decision will be entirely yours'.
 
Literally, (and a little uncommon relative to modern English as yukio_michael pointed out) it means.

On your head (your conscience, your fault) be (something is, something exists) it (the bad thing we're discussing) if..

Thats the breakdown of the wording. As made of stone said, it means
'the responsibility for the result of that action or decision will be entirely yours'.
 
It sounds like a Shakespearean or old English expression. It could also be worded, "Be it on your own head ......" But you wouldn't hear this anywhere in the modern world (except maybe in a few subcultures).
 
皆さん大変お世話になっています Tintin のある巻にでてきたものです。タンタンは古い(1930年代以降)ので、古い熟語などがいっぱい使われているのでしょう。
 

Nekocat chan, forgive me, but I can't read and understand Japanese...what does that mean??

 
Well, not really 古い - most of the dialogue there is still everyday English. 'Be it' is still alive in today's 熟語. Usually it's found in the expression, 'so be it'.

In that dialogue, 'be it' is used to convey emphasis in a way that implies 'okay, but be prepared for whatever happens and don't say I didn't warn you'.

If you remove this emphasis from

'But on your own head be it if we have trouble from this scorpion, Wolff!'

it would become:

'But on your own head it will be if we have trouble from this scorpion, Wolff!'

The result then becomes just a mere statement.

Been reading 月世界探検 again, haven't you?
 
it means, "let it be on your head..." its kinda like saying "so be it", you dont conjugate the verb "be".
 
And it is fairly commonly in use in modern English. If you said to someone "On your own head be it", everyone would know what you meant.
 
What a wonderful resource of human knowledge we can tap into! You all are wealth of info, literally. ありがとう!
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…