What's new

たことがある VS たことがあった

zuotengdazuo

Sempai
8 Dec 2019
830
19
28
その少女の貌を、折紙は見たことがあったのである。

Hi. I know the underlined pattern is used to talk about past experience.
What would be the difference between たことがある and たことがあった?
Are they the same?
Thank you.
 
Needless to say, ~たことがあった is the past form of ~たことがある, so the reference point in time is past in the former, whereas it's now in the latter. The meaning is often the same, but not always so.
e.g.
遅刻したことがよくある。
遅刻したことがよくあった。

よくある means that the speaker is often late for school even now, but よくあった shows that it's past like "used to", i.e., it's not so now.

As for your example, the difference is subtle, but 見たことがあるのである has a nuance that 折紙 has just remembered her face now.
 
Thank you! So ~たことがあった in the op example suggests that 折紙 used to remember her face but can't do that now, right?
 
No. よく is the key in my examples. The meaning is the same for your case, as I wrote "the difference is subtle". 折紙 remembers her face.
 
Back
Top Bottom