What's new

Another は vs が question...

Joined
Feb 19, 2017
Messages
55
Hi again.

Found another couple of phrases in my textbook where I'm unsure if the different use of は and が have a specific purpose.

The first sentence: ねこがなにかもってきましたか。
The second sentence: ねこはなにかたべましたか。

Is there any particular reason why が was used in the first and は in the second?

Thx.
 

Toritoribe

松葉解禁
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Feb 22, 2008
Messages
14,837
Ratings
2 1,539
Are you using Genki, right? Isn't the first sentence ねこがなにかもってきました without か?
 
Joined
Feb 19, 2017
Messages
55
Are you using Genki, right? Isn't the first sentence ねこがなにかもってきました without か?
Correct.

I don't know why I put the か particle in here (maybe because I was tired when I made the post). I was actually going to ask if が was used in the first line because its a statement being made, while は was used because a question is being asked. I looked around a little online to see if this was the case but didn't find any sources which supported my hypothesis so I didn't bother to bring it up.

Is this along the right track or is it something else?
 
Joined
Nov 12, 2014
Messages
174
Ratings
59
Correct.

I don't know why I put the か particle in here (maybe because I was tired when I made the post). I was actually going to ask if が was used in the first line because its a statement being made, while は was used because a question is being asked. I looked around a little online to see if this was the case but didn't find any sources which supported my hypothesis so I didn't bother to bring it up.

Is this along the right track or is it something else?
I think it has more to do with the action being performed, and by whom (i.e., less to do with being a questions vs. statement).
 
Top