- 14 Apr 2016
- 528
- 33
- 44
あと「で」デザート「に」アイスクリーム「を」食べましょう。
I have a question.
Why is the first one で? Isn't あと the time where an action take place?
A Dictionary of Japanese Particle, p.123: Indicates when an action takes/took place.
Actually, in the same book, p.20: indicates the time when an action or process happens or happened.
Of course, the example provided are different in both particles.
For で, we're told:
① Indicates the age of a person (not the case here).
② Imposes a time limit on an action or occurrence (not the case here).
③ Shows the time period when something occurred/occurs, often found in では and でも patterns. Both examples provided for this particular function use では and でも so it's hard to tell if it can be used in any other contexts. If I had to guess I'd say this the right answer but I'm not sure.
Help anyone?
I have a question.
Why is the first one で? Isn't あと the time where an action take place?
A Dictionary of Japanese Particle, p.123: Indicates when an action takes/took place.
Actually, in the same book, p.20: indicates the time when an action or process happens or happened.
Of course, the example provided are different in both particles.
For で, we're told:
① Indicates the age of a person (not the case here).
② Imposes a time limit on an action or occurrence (not the case here).
③ Shows the time period when something occurred/occurs, often found in では and でも patterns. Both examples provided for this particular function use では and でも so it's hard to tell if it can be used in any other contexts. If I had to guess I'd say this the right answer but I'm not sure.
Help anyone?